Agent Gibbs Posted August 15, 2013 Posted August 15, 2013 I like the official and that fan made art work for the same issue, I don't like the out of place "HD" logo, and conversely i like the fan made one because the HD logo has been rejigged into a more fitting font if the official one had a more fitting font i'd have no problems with it at all
Sheikah Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 It better get a 10 in EDGE. Cause if it doesn't... *shakes fist menacingly* I personally wouldn't give the original a 10, let alone a remake. As gorgeous as it was, I don't think the game was '10 material'. Majora's Mask, on the other hand...
Ronnie Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 I personally wouldn't give the original a 10, let alone a remake. As gorgeous as it was, I don't think the game was '10 material'. Majora's Mask, on the other hand... WHAT! It was easily 10 material, far better then Skyward Sword for starters, which actually did somehow get a 10. The game was amazing, my favourite ever. [removes you from my Xmas mass text list] :P
Wii Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 It certainly does not deserve a 10, nothing like it. They cut dungeons and added nothing new to the remake. Awful triforce quest in the original. Shattered my dreams of Spaceworld 2000. 10? You must be joking. ALTTP = 10 OOT = 10 Majora's Mask = 10 The WindWaker = 8.5 Twilight Princess = 9 Skyward Sword = 7 (and I'm feeling generous)
Andyliini Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Anyone else noticed that Nintendo Network -logo is absent in the European boxart of the game, but is there for the Japanese and American ones? I think it's just a mistake, but still.
Ronnie Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 It certainly does not deserve a 10, nothing like it. They cut dungeons and added nothing new to the remake. Awful triforce quest in the original. Shattered my dreams of Spaceworld 2000. 10? You must be joking. ALTTP = 10 OOT = 10 Majora's Mask = 10 The WindWaker = 8.5 Twilight Princess = 9 Skyward Sword = 7 (and I'm feeling generous) "Shattered my dreams of Spaceworld 2000" - ah that explains your post.
Fierce_LiNk Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 It certainly does not deserve a 10, nothing like it. They cut dungeons and added nothing new to the remake. Awful triforce quest in the original. Shattered my dreams of Spaceworld 2000. 10? You must be joking. ALTTP = 10 OOT = 10 Majora's Mask = 10 The WindWaker = 8.5 Twilight Princess = 9 Skyward Sword = 7 (and I'm feeling generous) I'd personally put TP a bit higher. 9.5 or even on a 10 itself as I adore it. Aside from that, it's about right. Skyward Sword definitely the weakest game, then followed by Wind Waker. Glad to see somebody else that shares the same views as me. Saying that, all these screens and boxes make me want it again. But...it's all and illusion!
Ville Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Oh, Carina of Thyme!:10 Majora's mmmm Ass+k: 10+ Wind Wanker: 9+ Twilight Excuuuuuuuse meee, Princess!: 8,5 Skyward Sword (in your pants): 8 Phantom Our Glasses: 9 Spirits Tracks: 8
Retro_Link Posted August 16, 2013 Author Posted August 16, 2013 Ocarina of Time - 10 Skyward Sword - 9 Wind Waker - 8.5 Majora's Mask - 8 Twilight Princess - 5 (TROLOLOLOLOL)
Fierce_LiNk Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Twilight Excuuuuuuuse meee, Princess!: 8,5 Phantom Our Glasses: 9 Seems legit. Also, Faq U Retro. You don't deserve the _Link title.
Agent Gibbs Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 OoT - 9 MM - 10 WW - 10 TP -7 SS -7.5 are we so devoid of new news were rating zelda games
bryanee Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Lists? I love lists. Ocarina of Time - 10/10 Link to the Past - 10/10 Twilight Princess - 9.5/10 Links Awakening - 9/10 Wind Waker - 8/10 Majoras Mask - 7/10 Skyward Sword - 6/10 Phantom Hourglass - Terrible/10 I've never played the Oracles and Minish games.
Wii Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 are we so devoid of new news were rating zelda games I am. I want news of the new Zelda. If Windwaker had added anything new then I might be interested in repurchasing it. It didn't so I'm not.
Cube Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Ocarina of Time: 9/10 Majora's Mask: 10/10 Wind Waker: 10/10 Twilight Princess: 8.5/10 Skyward Sword: 8/10 Minish Cap: 9.5/10
Hero-of-Time Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Lists? I love lists. Ocarina of Time - 10/10 Link to the Past - 10/10 Twilight Princess - 9.5/10 Links Awakening - 9/10 Wind Waker - 8/10 Majoras Mask - 7/10 Skyward Sword - 6/10 Phantom Hourglass - Terrible/10 I've never played the Oracles and Minish games.
Shorty Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 I had no idea Skyward Sword was so meagrely recieved here, I thought it was outstanding, 100x the game Twilight Sepia Princess was.
Eddage Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 A Link to the Past - 10/10 Ocarina of Time - 10/10 Majora's Mask - 8.5/10 Wind Waker - 7/10 (never finished it) Twilight Princess - 7.5/10 Skyward Sword - 7/10 (never finished it) I'm seriously hoping this HD version of Wind Waker will up my view of it!
Rummy Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Interested in why OoT is a 9 vs 10 for you both @Agent Gibbs and @Cube? Did you play it at its original launch, or later/after the others?
-Dem0- Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 The home console Zeldas that I finished. Wind Waker- 10 Ocarina of Time- 10 Skyward Sword- 9.5 Twilight Princess- 9.0 Majora's Mask- 8.0
Ronnie Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 In order: Wind Waker - 10 Majora's Mask - 10 Ocarina of Time - 10 Skyward Sword - 9 Twilight Princess - 9
Cube Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Interested in why OoT is a 9 vs 10 for you both Agent Gibbs and Cube? Did you play it at its original launch, or later/after the others? I played it a launch (well, a few months later), but I lost interest at some point. I returned to it and completed it after I finished Majora's Mask.
Ronnie Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 I had no idea Skyward Sword was so meagrely recieved here, I thought it was outstanding, 100x the game Twilight Sepia Princess was. Ridiculous hand-holding, minimal exploration, an empty sky, forgettable soundtrack and three or four extremely unmemorable dungeons. I loved it but I can see why it isn't that well loved. Felt far too safe.
Agent Gibbs Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Interested in why OoT is a 9 vs 10 for you both @Agent Gibbs and @Cube? Did you play it at its original launch, or later/after the others? Yeah i bought it a week or so after launch for the N64 and loved the game, having previously only played the 11/10 Alltp i fell in love with the series because of these two. However i don't feel its a 10/10, maybe its a 9.5/10, but Majora's Mask felt so much more refined realistically though OoT and MM are the same game, and missing the third chapter My only issue with it was the water temple, hated it so much it stole the extra point/half point Now OoT 3D is a 9.5 or 10/10 and almost on par with MM 2d Zeldas A Link to the Past 11/10 Oracle of Ages/Seasons 10/10 The Legend of Zelda 10/10 Minish cap 9.99/10 A links awakening 9/10 The Legend of Zelda Adventure of Link 9/10 quasi 3d Zeldas Spirit Tracks 6/10 Phantom Hourglass 5.5/10 (probably being too generous)
Hero-of-Time Posted August 16, 2013 Posted August 16, 2013 Ridiculous hand-holding, minimal exploration, an empty sky, forgettable soundtrack and three or four extremely unmemorable dungeons. I loved it but I can see why it isn't that well loved. Felt far too safe. + motion controls.
Recommended Posts