Yes. That Maddox review hit so many nails on so many heads.
Although i enjoyed Prometheus, i don't like it when people try to explain bad storytelling by saying 'it asks so many questions'. That is fine, when you are asking hypothetical 'what if...' questions, but not questions like 'why the hell would that character do that' or 'why did he just die, for no apparent reason.'
Having to try and cobble together your own plot after the film probably means the film was badly written.
EDIT: Oh, and i'll add this here