Jump to content
NEurope
Smalldude76

Rate the Above Poster's Avatar and Signature

Recommended Posts

I love it!!! Would be funny if you put a white beard on here as well! :p

 

9.8/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Its ok but missing most of the elements usually included in a signature. and its too dark. 7.

 

There is no pre-reqs to a sig.. i.e. you dont HAVE to have a border.

 

 

ipaul: if you can point to the reference for the lemon caus i dont really get it but if i imagined i did 7/10 :yay:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's from a Radiohead song, Everything in its right place. And you get 9 (Y)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
There is no pre-reqs to a sig.. i.e. you dont HAVE to have a border.

 

 

ipaul: if you can point to the reference for the lemon caus i dont really get it but if i imagined i did 7/10 :yay:

 

alright, its missing too many to be that good.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Firstly Buttons, A lovely 8/10!

 

Secondly in regard to this:

jogablue.png

 

I believe that is a is a fantastic abstract signature and deserved of a 9/10 if not 10/10! It is no way "too dark". The use of light sources is brilliant and shows some real skill.

 

As AeroScap states there are no pre-reqs for a signature, as long as it is artistic such as Paj's. His is flowing and just totally gorgeous! Emasher you really should look about at some real graphics forums and understand the skill and time it takes to learn and make something such as Paj's. Right now just are just sounding grumpy and attempting to establish yourself as a supreme graphics matter when frankly what you produce isn't anything special. Sorry to be harsh but.... meh.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Firstly Buttons, A lovely 8/10!

 

Secondly in regard to this:

jogablue.png

 

I believe that is a is a fantastic abstract signature and deserved of a 9/10 if not 10/10! It is no way "too dark". The use of light sources is brilliant and shows some real skill.

 

As AeroScap states there are no pre-reqs for a signature, as long as it is artistic such as Paj's. His is flowing and just totally gorgeous! Emasher you really should look about at some real graphics forums and understand the skill and time it takes to learn and make something such as Paj's. Right now just are just sounding grumpy and attempting to establish yourself as a supreme graphics matter when frankly what you produce isn't anything special. Sorry to be harsh but.... meh.

 

 

"hear hear" *bashes table in agreement*

 

Omg Fresh I luff your sigs! maybe its the size of them caus the more compact it is the more time you have to put into it to make it look good.

 

It may be a bit bias but minimalism is my thing and your sig is the poster boy for the medium! that and death note live action ftw! (plus top notch bleach sig from before :P)

 

10/10 !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yours is awesome. Very Differerent to other stuff on here, I love it.

 

9.9/10

 

--

 

I've just seasoned mine up a bit! :yay:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Firstly Buttons, A lovely 8/10!

 

Secondly in regard to this:

jogablue.png

 

I believe that is a is a fantastic abstract signature and deserved of a 9/10 if not 10/10! It is no way "too dark". The use of light sources is brilliant and shows some real skill.

 

As AeroScap states there are no pre-reqs for a signature, as long as it is artistic such as Paj's. His is flowing and just totally gorgeous! Emasher you really should look about at some real graphics forums and understand the skill and time it takes to learn and make something such as Paj's. Right now just are just sounding grumpy and attempting to establish yourself as a supreme graphics matter when frankly what you produce isn't anything special. Sorry to be harsh but.... meh.

 

Honestly, I've never really liked your style, It just gets old after a while.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Honestly, I've never really liked your style, It just gets old after a while.

 

Emasher. This is the rate your sig thread, not the make a bitchy comment about someone that doesn't like your sigs that much thread.

 

And if you are going to make a comment, at least still rate the sig above you.

 

--

 

It's nice, I like the christmas feel you've got going on with it. It would be nice if your next sig is someting with a different style to it though, I want to see what else you can come up with! :)

 

7/10

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't worry man! I got your back!

 

I can see that the original sig had a background picture but i cant make it out.

The two font approach works wonders, usually you want to be keeping tot he same one but yours works great. Maybe update it to the latest heroes theme? Origins is it?

 

and christmas Hayden Panettiere yumm.

 

Just up the picture quality of the sig (very easy) and it will score an 8/10.

atn 7/10 :P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Honestly, I've never really liked your style, It just gets old after a while.

 

Emasher. This is the rate your sig thread, not the make a bitchy comment about someone that doesn't like your sigs that much thread.

 

And if you are going to make a comment, at least still rate the sig above you.

 

Thank-you Haggis, The point you raise is totally unrelated. The theory of my "style" getting old is quite pointless. If you want me to prove my versatility you can glance through my back-catalog.

 

This aside, Emasher if you rate yourself so highly get on a graphic forum, look around. Notice that alot of the best signature makers are doing very simular style to that of myself and Paj's which your. You're ego really needs taking down some.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've never said my signatures were that good.

 

Though alot of people have told me that they like them.

 

My point is it just gets tiring seeing decay style after half the posts on the forum.

 

Emasher. This is the rate your sig thread, not the make a bitchy comment about someone that doesn't like your sigs that much thread.

 

And if you are going to make a comment, at least still rate the sig above you.

 

I think its a fair comment.

 

I thought the general rule was that if you didn't rate the signature above you the next person who posts rates the last persons who gave a rating.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Dislike of new sig, 2.981/10 as the Rabbid thing is overdone, out of date and the image itself is low quality

 

That, and I look at it and find myself disliking it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My point is it just gets tiring seeing decay style after half the posts on the forum.

 

This only proves my point. You clearly don't even know what a "decay style" looks like. Have a look :

 

freshscarlettjdc6.jpg

^NOT DECAY^

freshatneuropecx8.jpg

^NOT DECAY^

freshevaai8.jpg

^NOT DECAY^

freshdivedl6.jpg

^NOT DECAY^

 

freshsamusangelsp5.jpg

^THIS IS^

 

You need to start understanding how something is made before you make vague, generalizing statements. /teacher disabled

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

10/10

 

Looks great, fantastic font, great style, lovely size.

 

Time for the Xmas sig...although I think I'll make a new one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×