Jump to content
N-Europe

[SPOILERS!!] The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword


Recommended Posts

Posted

Bought on day one, finished today...

 

Would I be deemed greedy if I said I wanted a little more???

 

Being declared a prequel to the series I wanted a bit more history. Tell me about the Sheikah tribe, I have yet to see a 'tribe' just one or two members per game. What of the Gerudo? Zoras? Goron society? For two games running now there has been a Gerudo Desert without any Gerudo...?

 

This is certainly a good game, but I feel it uses and borrows too much from other Zeldas ('restoring the master sword' - WW, 'reviving a formerly sealed evil' TP) - which makes it feel tedious early on, we've pretty much done this before. Sigh, I don't know anymore, maybe I'm just growing out of these games...

 

Sadly, for me the music was poor, only a few memorable tracks and even that is more of a ringing in the head from just hearing the music for extensive periods. The desert/time shift mixes were lovely - the harp songs were weak. I've got four Zelda soundtracks in my iTunes collection, but I don't see a use for SS.

 

One thing I did love, was the desert ocean..! Such a beautiful and ingenious idea. Now if the pirates were Gerudo, with a certain male ancestor... Would have been the highlight of the game...

 

Credits due I like how they made the overal game feel 'different'. For some reason though it makes me appreciate TP a bit more.

  • Replies 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
  King_V said:
Bought on day one, finished today...

 

Would I be deemed greedy if I said I wanted a little more???

 

Being declared a prequel to the series I wanted a bit more history. Tell me about the Sheikah tribe, I have yet to see a 'tribe' just one or two members per game. What of the Gerudo? Zoras? Goron society? For two games running now there has been a Gerudo Desert without any Gerudo...?

 

This is certainly a good game, but I feel it uses and borrows too much from other Zeldas ('restoring the master sword' - WW, 'reviving a formerly sealed evil' TP) - which makes it feel tedious early on, we've pretty much done this before. Sigh, I don't know anymore, maybe I'm just growing out of these games...

 

Sadly, for me the music was poor, only a few memorable tracks and even that is more of a ringing in the head from just hearing the music for extensive periods. The desert/time shift mixes were lovely - the harp songs were weak. I've got four Zelda soundtracks in my iTunes collection, but I don't see a use for SS.

 

One thing I did love, was the desert ocean..! Such a beautiful and ingenious idea. Now if the pirates were Gerudo, with a certain male ancestor... Would have been the highlight of the game...

 

Credits due I like how they made the overal game feel 'different'. For some reason though it makes me appreciate TP a bit more.

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted
  King_V said:
I understand evil being reincarnated, but that doesn't exactly mean Ganondorf or the Gerudo are descendants of Demise.

 

I thought it meant Ganondorf was exactly that.

 

Have to say I thought the final boss whilst pretty damn cool was also pretty damn easy.

Posted
  bryanee said:
I thought it meant Ganondorf was exactly that.

 

Have to say I thought the final boss whilst pretty damn cool was also pretty damn easy.

 

His more Ganondorf's predecessor than ancestor. Reincarnation just means someone being born with that same malice. It could have been a Goron.

Posted

Just finished. Two things before I post more in depth thoughts later:

 

1) The most fun I've ever had playing a Zelda game. Loved every single moment of it, besides 2 small-ish sections which I hated.

 

2) The final boss was very, very, VERY anti-climatic. I mean shit, the boss before last had more going for it.

 

I can't believe it's over :(

Posted

Its my favourite zelda game of all time. i just loved the story so much. all the characters were amazing. Link and Zelda's relationship was the highlight of the game for me. Also i dont understand why people are complaining about the music, it was an epic score.

Posted
  King_V said:
His more Ganondorf's predecessor than ancestor. Reincarnation just means someone being born with that same malice. It could have been a Goron.

 

I agree. However, I don't miss the Gerudo (although it would be nice to see another male). In TP it made sense - the species died out after their only male was locked away.

Posted
  Cube said:
I agree. However, I don't miss the Gerudo (although it would be nice to see another male). In TP it made sense - the species died out after their only male was locked away.

 

Speculative. A gossip stone in OOT states Gerudo women seek Hyrulian mates.

Posted

alot seem to be complaining about backstorys of other games not being filled in. this is never gonna happen, this is just how nintendo do zelda games. they will have a few things link up (in ww you went down to hyrule, in tp gannon was sealed away and the temple of time) but for the most part they create the game in a timeline and then all the gameplay elements are pretty much created for the purpose of that game, not so they can fill in the blanks of later games that were made 10 years ago. that is just how nintendo have, and always will do things.

 

besides do you really need little references to tell you stuff like 'here is where the gerudos started ' here is where the zoras started' it doesnt matter, they started somewhere, you can use your imagination.

Posted
  Reveal hidden contents
Posted

They seemed to have missed:

 

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted

well just finished the game

and i think its my favorite zelda, i fell more and more in love with it as it went along

 

the revelations that demise is reincarnated as Gannon/Gannondorf (or heavy hinting) helps to tie in how they are always reincarnated, its all part of demises endless curse, is a great idea overall

 

but it did leave me with a few questions

what was the land like before the first war between the 4th Goddess and Demise?

Assuming Hyrule and the Hylian are named in remembrance of the Goddess (since she assumes the role of Zelda), at which point did the Old Gods become more common knowledge? was this to divert the following generations from discussing the goddess or something?

What occurred in the millennia between demises destruction and the Skyloft events? nothing?

will it create another split timeline though is my biggest question! OoT had the Child and Adult timelines splitting off from each other due to returning to the past after defeating gannon and sealing the door preventing him.

In Skyward Sword they destroyed/Imprissoned demise in the past, presumably with Gihrahim (of the future) so therefore the past was theoretically free of Demise and

they then return to the Future where Demise is gone.

 

I'd rather not have another split timeline further convoluting the shaky timeline

 

But overall great game, erm is it too soon to say roll on Zelda 3DS?

Posted

Just finished it myself, with 47 hours on the clock. I loved the last dungeon, and the section leading up to the final boss was great too. I'm hoping for playable Demise in the next Smash Bros..

 

Great twist about Impa at the end - I realised that 'Grannie' was Impa about ten seconds before the reveal, although, looking back at it now, it was kinda obvious..

 

Skyward Sword now sits at number three in my list of favourite 3D Zeldas, behind OOT and MM. I think it was all the fetch quests that let it down for me - far too much unnecessary padding. Swordplay was fantastic though, as was the graphical style - I'd really like them to keep it for Zelda Wii U.

 

I've still got about ten pieces of heart to find, as well as some gratitude crystals, so I've still got plenty to do. :)

Posted

Just finished it, loved the final battle. Whoever designed Demise is a genius. The way his hair flows and body pulsates looks fantastic.

 

Overall I enjoyed the game but it's not in my top 5 Zelda games. I did really enjoy the cinematic scenes with Zelda. It took 25 years but I finally cared for the character.

 

One scene which I loved was when she decided to put herself to sleep, it was quite moving but couldn't help but think it could have been alot more emotional if there was voice acting. Yes, I went there.

 

I mean Link looks shocked, lowers his head and then just walks off. His childhood partner has just essentially gave up her life and thats all we get off him. :D

 

I really hated the animation used for Fi when she sang a song. Nintendo used the same facial animation for all the songs and it just looked like she was screaming. Annoyed the hell out of me everytime I watched it.

Posted

FINISHED

 

My god that was one hell of an ending.

 

The final dungeon was great... if head wrecking.... man I hate those kind of puzzles haha.

 

Since this is the SPOILERS thread not sure if I should tag this or not, but since Cube tagged what he did above I guess I should Tag this too....

 

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted
  Mokong X-C said:

 

Oh yeah did anyone get all the Heart Pieces? I'm 3 short of 100%.... I'm thinking there's one for the Sword Mini game where you chop the bamboo tree... I can't get more than 28 cuts though, and I'm thinking the Fun FUn Island mini game has another for getting all the rings and the 50 rupee sqaure... but I can't get all the bloody rings never mind the 50 rupee square... no idea where the 3rd missing piece might be though.... I seem to have all the goddess cubes got as the dowsing is not bringing up anything so it can't be from one of those?

 

Ah wait I just remembered that the Thunder Dragon has a piece I didn't get yet... good thing I made a copy of the file before the final boss too so I can go back to get my 100%... though if I'm right about the other two pieces it'll take a lot of retrying :heh:

 

Also something else occured to me...

 

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted
  Mokong X-C said:

2 parralell timelines I can handle.... 3... that's too much :heh:

 

I had very similar fear in my post above, i hope it wasn't the start of another split, i really hope not

 

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted

With regards to "the timeline", the architecture and layout of the land is probably one thing not fully considered. While there are many links and references, it's not 100%.

 

Mainly because having the same Hyrule in all games would be boring.

Posted
  Agent Gibbs said:
I had very similar fear in my post above, i hope it wasn't the start of another split, i really hope not

 

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted

Just finished the Batreaux quest, with Beedle being the last to give me gratitude crystals. Bit of a useless reward, though - shame you don't get the Hylian shield for that, as I don't know if I can be bothered with Boss Rush.

Posted

people who want voice acting are missing a big point. the voices in the game now(which are amazing) are done by japanese. if the whole game was voice acted, the japanese version would be great! and i wouldn just end up listening to that, with subtitles. it would basicly be similar to how it is now.

 

the english versions voice acting would be subpar, cringeworthy, and embaressing. its a fact clear as day.


×
×
  • Create New...