Taken as a whole it was pretty good I think, though the pre-show had bigger reveals with Guacamelee 2 and Spenlunky 2 tbh.
It's also a bit dishonest to go on about how "E3 was only half the show" and then have the vast majority of this one show the same games as E3! Destiny, Monster Hunter, COD, Battlefront, Spiderman, Detroit, God of War, Horizon DLC, Shadow etc...
That said, Concrete Genie looked phenomenal, and was my personal highlight. It looked fresh and beautiful! Wonder what the game will play like.
Couldn't judge Sucker Punch's new game from just cinematics.