The fish Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 I say we do nothing for now. Lynching a townie will just make us feel guilty, and a Mafioso would be through luck alone. Vote: No Lynch.
Raining_again Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 I say we do nothing for now. Lynching a townie will just make us feel guilty, and a Mafioso would be through luck alone. Vote: No Lynch. This is the thing, lynching a good is only gonna get the mafia closer to a majority. Same goes for non active players.
Tellyn Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 This is the thing, lynching a good is only gonna get the mafia closer to a majority. Same goes for non active players. Precisely. Doing nothing during the day isn't as horrific as you all make out - if we lynch a townie, the mafia also get a definite townie kill again during the night. That's two needless kills when it could have been one.
Mr-Paul Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 I agree with all that's been said. Random lynches are only any good in the later stages of the game, where there are so few players that there is a higher chances of getting a mafioso by chance. We've got quite a bit of info from the discussion today, so I will vote VOTE: NO LYNCH
Cube Posted December 4, 2008 Author Posted December 4, 2008 Maase (2): MoogleViper, ,LazyBoy No Lynch (11): Dannyboy-the-Dane, Tellyn, Mundi, Jonnas, Gizmo, Zell, ShadowV7, Raining_again, The fish, mr-paul 13 is a majority.
Ellmeister Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 Not much else to say really, last few pages have ended up with nothing conclusive to use. No information from me. Vote: No lynch I don't think Jonnas is pinky by the way, PntB have nothing to do with investigating I thought. Also Jonnas should have had an idea that being pinky would have led to him to realise his investigative techniques couldn't have been all that. As for the hiding behind things, my speculation is they are a puppet? You know, going off stage hiding etc etc blah.
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 Not much else to say really, last few pages have ended up with nothing conclusive to use. No information from me. Vote: No lynch I don't think Jonnas is pinky by the way, PntB have nothing to do with investigating I thought. Also Jonnas should have had an idea that being pinky would have led to him to realise his investigative techniques couldn't have been all that. As for the hiding behind things, my speculation is they are a puppet? You know, going off stage hiding etc etc blah. But he IS a mouse. What cartoon mice are there with investigate powers?
ShadowV7 Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 Basil the Mouse Detective or something? From a Disney film.
Tellyn Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 Basil the Mouse Detective or something? From a Disney film. I was just about to say the exact same thing! One more vote to end the day and get the ball rolling again, by the way.
Eenuh Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 Basil the Mouse Detective or something? From a Disney film. I thought it was all about kid's shows though, not films, so I don't know... Anyway, last vote. Vote: No Lynch
Molly Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 I am craving more information! I agree though, there doesn't seem much sense in a random lynching so... Vote: No lynch
Jonnas Posted December 4, 2008 Posted December 4, 2008 Note: I am not a mouse. I am a blob that hides behind curtains. Vicar is the mouse.
Cube Posted December 4, 2008 Author Posted December 4, 2008 Maase (2): MoogleViper, ,LazyBoy No Lynch (13): Dannyboy-the-Dane, Tellyn, Mundi, Jonnas, Gizmo, Zell, ShadowV7, Raining_again, The fish, mr-paul, Ellmiester, Tellyn 13 is a majority. Day 2 is Over. Night 2 Begins Now.
Cube Posted December 6, 2008 Author Posted December 6, 2008 Night 2 Has Ended The train was upset. Not only had his protector failed to arrive, but his passengers had also not turned up. Had they been sent somewhere else? --- The boy used his mind control device. Two peoples' bodies were temporarily swapped for the night. The boy turned around to see some odd creature...it sort of looked somewhat like a puppy. Then it started singing. The more the boy complained the louder the thing sang. The boy packed his bags. ShadowV7 has left. He was Dexter (Dexter's Laboratory). He was good. --- The usual folk roamed round in the night. Some asking questions. A bear soaked a dog, who inquired about a man. A confused dog and a mouse soon joined in on quizzing this man. --- A fox was snooping round, his mind still felt fuzzy from earlier that night. This night there were two people instead of one. All a sudden the fox found himself falling into a bucket and landing in a world filled with dinosaurs. Back at the fox's house, someone was fixing things. "Who wants to watch something where one of the main characters doesn't talk" said the man at his desk. He reached for the button. UNABLE TO FIND SHOW He pressed it again. UNABLE TO FIND SHOW "Darn it! You may be safe tonight, but you won't be safe forever". --- There are 23 players left. 12 is a majority. Beggilax Coolness Bears Dannyboy-the-Dane DomJcg Dyson Eenuh Elmiester Gizmo Jamba jayseven Jonnas LazyBoy Maase MadDog Molly MoogleViper mr-paul Mundi Raining_Again Tellyn The fish Vicar Zell Day 3 begins now.
Jonnas Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Maase is innocent. I can confirm this. He's definately good. Other than that, I got nothing. And who was the dog?
Mundi Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 I think I got scrambled with my Info The usual folk roamed round in the night. Some asking questions. A bear soaked a dog, who inquired about a man. A confused dog and a mouse soon joined in on quizzing this man. I´m a dog so I´m assuming that´s me in the write up being confused.
Vicar Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Well my info tells me that Tellyn is good and I'm alive and breathing no idea what the singing dog it tho.
Ellmeister Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Nothing of any use here I'm afraid. Mundi I think there are 2 dogs in that write-up, the one being soaked by a bear and the confused dog. Are you definitely the confused one?
Eenuh Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 I can't even tell from these write-ups who is me, so I have no idea what is going on...
Ellmeister Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 So..Vicar accused Maase of being evil, he is good. Vicar accuses Tellyn of being good, is he evil???? Vicar any chance you could speculate as to whether there is a possibility that you may be a dumb cop?
Mundi Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Well my info tells me that Tellyn is good and I'm alive and breathing no idea what the singing dog it tho. And by Tellyn´s own theory of you being a dump cop makes him evil right? Nothing of any use here I'm afraid. Mundi I think there are 2 dogs in that write-up, the one being soaked by a bear and the confused dog. Are you definitely the confused one? Hmm it says that the soaked bear quizzes a man and a confused dog and a mouse joined it. I read it first that there was only one dog. So I was either soaked (not sure what it means to me) or I´m confused. Either way my info is circumstantial and I doubt said player means harm. Anyway I found out that a certain player is a Fireman If we want to discern if Vicar is a dumb cop it would help if we know who he is.
Ellmeister Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 I think it has to be fireman sam, who is almost definitely good. Okay Mundi good idea, vicar any chance in giving us a clue or something at least? Right now Tellyn is looking pretty suspicious just because of his own dumb cop theory (irony?)
Dyson Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Here's my thinking. No one. You may not like it, but everyone you accuse or try to lynch is going to try to defend themselves and proclaim their innocence. No one has any information, and the chances of randomly picking out a mafioso are slim. The mafia may pick someone off during the night unless someone interferes by chance, but let's just see what the next day brings. Vote: No Lynch Precisely. Doing nothing during the day isn't as horrific as you all make out - if we lynch a townie, the mafia also get a definite townie kill again during the night. That's two needless kills when it could have been one. An interesting perception on voting No Lynch, whereas it's commonly accepted that a vote for no lynch is a day that's been wasted by the townies, it almost seems as if he wants the night phase to start and the day to go to waste so to speak. This seemed a bit fishy to me. Combined with this... The odds that Beggilax is a townie are too great, and we're still on day 2 for Christ's sake. Is Beggilax real life friends with Mundi? If so, he can tell him to start playing. I'm thinking there is a possibility that both Tellyn and Beggilax are part of the Mafia and even though Beggilax is inactive, a vote for him does mean that he's a man down and needs an extra person taken out to reach majority. Plus he seems quite keen to get Beggilax specifically back in the game, instead of pointing out all the inactive people. Do what you will, I could be completely wrong. I'm just giving you another possibility, anything's possible in mafia games - again, I just don't want to help kill someone who could be of use to us. Yes I am defending Maase, it's the big twist of this particular mafia game. But really, I think it's too early on to be spilling blood. I don't trust Vicar... I don't trust Maase. I don't trust anyone at the moment, we're still on day 1. I'm not going to be responsible for helping to kill off a potential fellow townsperson this early on. To me, these quotes seemed to just shout out "Look at me, I'm innocent!" from him. It seemed as if he was adamant in trying to over prove his innocence and it stood out to me just a little too much. These things combined just made Tellyn stick out a bit during yesterday's proceedings and flagged him up as suspicious to me when reading through what was going on. On pure hunch basis, I'm going to Vote: Tellyn.
Vicar Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Let´s just say you know who i am it´s pretty obvious
Mundi Posted December 6, 2008 Posted December 6, 2008 Well I guess I´m stupid then Vicar :Þ Vote: Tellyn
Recommended Posts