The Pirate Mafia

[Jonnas]

I might feel more comfortable going after Cube instead today.

 

If we think this is the first time that the parrot has killed then it is likely because his non-kill power is less useful than the other powers the mafia have. Thus it may be better to kill someone else.

 

I might feel more comfortable going after Cube instead today.

 

If we think this is the first time that the parrot has killed then it is likely because his non-kill power is less useful than the other powers the mafia have. Thus it may be better to kill someone else.

 

Or, you can vote for Tales right now and we'll know what the parrot does. Staying in the dark about the parrot's power is letting the mafia continue to manipulate others. We lynch the parrot, we'll know for sure which one of you or Cube is evil.

 

If we lynch Cube first, and we made a mistake, then it would be very costly. But of course, if you are mafia, you know this, and will stall. If you aren't, voting for Tales is your best course of action.

[ReZourceman]

Or, you can vote for Tales right now and we'll know what the parrot does. Staying in the dark about the parrot's power is letting the mafia continue to manipulate others. We lynch the parrot, we'll know for sure which one of you or Cube is evil.

 

If we lynch Cube first, and we made a mistake, then it would be very costly. But of course, if you are mafia, you know this, and will stall. If you aren't, voting for Tales is your best course of action.

 

..............Lol.

[Mr-Paul]

The mafia has either 3 or 4 people out of the 10 of us left. Lynch someone we aren't even sure is a parrot/mafia, then turns out to be town, and then a night kill will leave us with 8 players left, 3 or 4 mafia, with someone who has made about 2 posts all game (fish), the mafia will be firmly in control. That's why I'm much more in favour of lynching nintendohnut or cube, who have a lot more to be suspicious of than tales, who is just the target switcher and parrot because jonnas says so.

[ReZourceman]

Precisely.

 

How is Cube not under more suspicsion. Most people just seem to accept that he tells stories to people (no evidence) using his cutlass (why would he need that if story telling) and that he doesn't know what his power is doing, and no one else can say what its doing because it isn't effecting them either.

 

Ridiculous.

 

(PS I am aware my vote is still on Nintendohnut, but I'm more than comfortable voting for him or Cube, and finally Jonnas who has been voting with them/backing them up/attacking me for half the match)

[Cube]

I posted everything I could find about my power: Sméagol ended up locking himself in his jail because (I'm 90% sure) of me - so I made a mental note to avoid targeting Sméagol from then on (as I probably would have ended up doing the same), and I wasn't able to affect your (ReZ's) power last night because you were already roleblocked.

[Jonnas]

Precisely.

 

How is ReZ not under more suspicsion. Most people just seem to accept that he finds something about people (no evidence) using his cooking (why would he need that if investigating) and that he doesn't know what his power is doing, and no one else can say what its doing because it isn't effecting them either.

Ridiculous.

 

Fix'd it for you.

 

The mafia has either 3 or 4 people out of the 10 of us left. Lynch someone we aren't even sure is a parrot/mafia, then turns out to be town, and then a night kill will leave us with 8 players left, 3 or 4 mafia, with someone who has made about 2 posts all game (fish), the mafia will be firmly in control. That's why I'm much more in favour of lynching nintendohnut or cube, who have a lot more to be suspicious of than tales, who is just the target switcher and parrot because jonnas says so.

 

Who is the parrot, then? Someone has to be the parrot, and I'm sure as hell not buying that "I'm a ghost that makes...something...to people"

 

And for the record, no I don't fully trust Dohnut or Cube, but at least their stories have less holes than Tales'.

[Nintendohnut]

Tales, do you think I am the killer?

 

Already addressed all of the points in mr-paul's last post so I won't bother doing so again. The fact is he is the only remaining player who didn't vote for either mafia member. He can dress is up however he likes but that's a provable fact *shrug* And I've explained why I did what I did every day in the long post. Will post my targets later if people are desperate, I've posted them before (maybe a few days ago now...) but I'll do it again. Just got back from work so need food then I'll go through my PMs etc.

 

Zell's viewing the thread, let's hope he makes a post.

[Cube]

I think it's a fair point that mr-paul wasn't in the game for when he voted for MadDog.

[Zell]

That was a fair amount to read. I reckon the best course of action is to lynch Tales now and if we're wrong we've got a list of other people to vote off next.

 

Vote: Tales

[Mr-Paul]

Yeah. I missed the Dazz vote due to being at work and voted when I got home. You can't say its like I was defending him or reluctant like you were with Maddog's lynch.

Eenuh was pretty inactive as well when this was her character.

And that lynch of Dazz was led by jayseven, whose views have been consistent with mine since I've been back in the game.

Unfortunately he's not been around today as it is his birthday.

 

ou'reto try and twist it that I'm bad because Eenuh was pretty inactive and I voted for Dazz late because I was at work and everyone else including mafia had already voted as the evidence wasnt able to

 

Yeah. I missed the Dazz vote due to being at work and voted when I got home. You can't say its like I was defending him or reluctant like you were with Maddog's lynch.

Eenuh was pretty inactive as well when this was her character.

And that lynch of Dazz was led by jayseven, whose views have been consistent with mine since I've been back in the game.

Unfortunately he's not been around today as it is his birthday.

 

You're trying to twist it that I'm bad because Eenuh was pretty inactive and I voted for Dazz late because I was at work and everyone else including mafia had already voted as the evidence wasnt able to be argued against.

 

And do you want to address the point that you said you were willing to be lynched if you were wrong about jayseven (which you clearly were)?

 

Sorry, on my phone and silly post submitted half way through!

 

God I hope Tales is by some twist of fate mafia now. If he's not, it will totally confirm 100% to me that nintendohnut, cube and jonnas are evil.

[Nintendohnut]

Lol. Confirm 100%? Either you're a completely ruthless mafia member or you are going to have some pretty epic egg on your face when I die/the game ends. Seriously, I will say one more time, I am loyal to the captain. I wonder why Tales targeted me last night if he thought I was evil? I guess we'll find out if he was lying soon but if he was telling the truth there was a chance he would boost my ability...

 

Also mr-paul, what if when Tales is lynched he IS evil? By your logic if he's good I'm evil. So does that mean if he's evil I'm good? Or will I still be under suspicion? Will you twist that one into a Dazz situation as well?

 

I am slightly concerned, only because if mr-paul isn't a mafia member we've reached majority without jay and the fish, which means it is likely at least one mafia member will have voted. If so then we may be wrong, but I think if Tales is evil we can be pretty sure Rez is too.

[ReZourceman]

but I think if Tales is evil we can be pretty sure Rez is too.

 

You'll have to explain that one to me...

[Tales]

Your loss. Now the mafia will be one step closer to majority.

[Mr-Paul]

Don't blame me!

[Nintendohnut]

Mostly the fact you wouldn't vote for him and laughed when someone gave you a valid reason to. Can you answer me this: why were you pouring 'some kind of sauce' on the 'one-eyed' pirate (who I assume is fish) on night 2? It can't be anyone else (who else would have some kind of sauce but the cook?)...

[Nintendohnut]

SECOND POST: Do you think I'm the killer Tales? (repeating as it was on the last page)

 

Yarrrr me targets, as requested

 

Night 1: Ellmeister (an apology for the Pokemafia which had just ended )

Night 2: Ellmeister (he outed a mafioso early)

Night 3: Me (I'd come out as protector so thought I'd be killed, but the mafia clearly had a plan for me to take flak for the kills)

Night 4: jayseven (when I revealed this people suspected jayseven too and it was 'yet another reason why I was evil, I was protecting a team mate clearly etc etc'. Not so obvious now)

Night 5: Dazz (as I explained I was pretty suspecting of him and didn't trust anyone else so I targeted him. I was hoping he'd appear as someone else in the write-up too as it would have cleared me as the 'young pirate' that I thought I was from the day before)

Night 6: Jonnas (because he defended me when mr-paul was baying for my blood, and seeing as he was right to trust me I thought he deserved some help too)

 

mr-paul I'm afraid I've forgotten your power, what has it again? I remember the part about not being able to die immediately, and your win condition, but what is your power? I ask because I have now revealed everything about what I have done etc. You haven't revealed much.

 

I also have a question about your whole 'two deaths cannonball' thing. You say that if you get 5 votes you'll be hit by a cannonball and lose your first life. Then if you can be lynched. Does the day end when you have 5 votes? Or would there be an interlude cut-scene thing by the Peeps and then it carried on? And anyway, what happens if/when there are 5 players left? One may be a mafia member, three townies, and you. But 5 people couldn't vote for you in that situation, so you wouldn't lose a life and would be unkillable. So how would that work? Basically you win once a certain number of players are dead, is that fair to say? I only ask because the whole '5 votes' thing sounds a bit weird as it could change massively as the game goes on.

[ReZourceman]

Mostly the fact you wouldn't vote for him and laughed when someone gave you a valid reason to. Can you answer me this: why were you pouring 'some kind of sauce' on the 'one-eyed' pirate (who I assume is fish) on night 2? It can't be anyone else (who else would have some kind of sauce but the cook?)...

 

The guy who can steal things?

[Nintendohnut]

Jonnas didn't target you on night one. So unless he stole something from you on night 2 and THEN poured it on the fish, somehow targeting two people that night, then you're lying. See?

[ReZourceman]

Jonnas didn't target you on night one. So unless he stole something from you on night 2 and THEN poured it on the fish, somehow targeting two people that night, then you're lying. See?

 

That is of course assuming that Jonnas has been truthful. And I suspect the crap out of him.

 

Or it was the supposed write-up changer....oh no sorry, he was making you look suspicious that night. :/

 

SECOND POST: Do you think I'm the killer Tales? (repeating as it was on the last page)

 

Yarrrr me targets, as requested

 

Night 1: Ellmeister (an apology for the Pokemafia which had just ended )

Night 2: Ellmeister (he outed a mafioso early)

Night 3: Me (I'd come out as protector so thought I'd be killed, but the mafia clearly had a plan for me to take flak for the kills)

Night 4: jayseven (when I revealed this people suspected jayseven too and it was 'yet another reason why I was evil, I was protecting a team mate clearly etc etc'. Not so obvious now)

Night 5: Dazz (as I explained I was pretty suspecting of him and didn't trust anyone else so I targeted him. I was hoping he'd appear as someone else in the write-up too as it would have cleared me as the 'young pirate' that I thought I was from the day before)

Night 6: Jonnas (because he defended me when mr-paul was baying for my blood, and seeing as he was right to trust me I thought he deserved some help too)

 

mr-paul I'm afraid I've forgotten your power, what has it again? I remember the part about not being able to die immediately, and your win condition, but what is your power? I ask because I have now revealed everything about what I have done etc. You haven't revealed much.

 

I also have a question about your whole 'two deaths cannonball' thing. You say that if you get 5 votes you'll be hit by a cannonball and lose your first life. Then if you can be lynched. Does the day end when you have 5 votes? Or would there be an interlude cut-scene thing by the Peeps and then it carried on? And anyway, what happens if/when there are 5 players left? One may be a mafia member, three townies, and you. But 5 people couldn't vote for you in that situation, so you wouldn't lose a life and would be unkillable. So how would that work? Basically you win once a certain number of players are dead, is that fair to say? I only ask because the whole '5 votes' thing sounds a bit weird as it could change massively as the game goes on.

 

So......the only nights where it actually states that you "protected" or "defended" the targets were on the day you defended Dazz and on the day you defended Jonnas (as you say)

 

Dazz of course being confirmed mafia and Jonnas' alignment, arguably heavily under debate.

[Nintendohnut]

 

That is of course assuming that Jonnas has been truthful. And I suspect the crap out of him.

 

Or it was the supposed write-up changer....oh no sorry, he was making you look suspicious that night. :/

 

That was precisely my point. The only way you could possibly have been pouring sauce on someone is if there was a write-up changer, unless you lied. so if you know you didn't target the fish that night, then there MUST be a write-up changer as the sauce pourer, as it wasn't jonnas, must've been you.

 

Jonnas has been able to show himself in every write up so far so we know his targets are real.

 

 

So......the only nights where it actually states that you "protected" or "defended" the targets were on the day you defended Dazz and on the day you defended Jonnas (as you say)

 

Dazz of course being confirmed mafia and Jonnas' alignment, arguably heavily under debate.

 

Yep. Can't say much about that which I haven't said already. I target Dazz cause he was suspicious to me and Jonnas because he backed me up. Read the epic posts above for more on those things.

 

Also I lolled at the inverted commas around protected and defended. Are you saying that in the write-ups where it says I was going to help someone that I wasn't protecting them? When, earlier on, I said 'it's pretty much accepted by everyone that I'm a protector' and you were all up in ma' face like 'oh i don't so ner' I was trying to say that whether people think I'm a townie or mafia, everyone thinks my power is to protect. The people who believe me just believe me, and the people who think I'm evil think I'm the mafia protector who protects when he doesn't kill. Of course that's a load of balls, but how are they to know when the write-ups are changed?

[ReZourceman]

Also I lolled at the inverted commas around protected and defended. Are you saying that in the write-ups where it says I was going to help someone that I wasn't protecting them? When, earlier on, I said 'it's pretty much accepted by everyone that I'm a protector' and you were all up in ma' face like 'oh i don't so ner' I was trying to say that whether people think I'm a townie or mafia, everyone thinks my power is to protect. The people who believe me just believe me, and the people who think I'm evil think I'm the mafia protector who protects when he doesn't kill. Of course that's a load of balls, but how are they to know when the write-ups are changed?

 

You protected someone you thought was suspicious....and then you protected someone who backed you up? Shouldn't you protect people who you suspect are going to be targeted to be killed.

 

You've gotta admit that it is strange that there were two protectors and a jailkeep, you know where I'm coming from and how it looks Dohnut....even if you're townie, you've gotta see that it looks really bad.

[Nintendohnut]

Yeah but the jailkeep was also a roleblocker, and if Zell is town then there were two other roleblockers as well. If Zell is proved to be lying it will look REALLY bad, but at this point I don't think it's THAT bad. The most 'evidence' there is that I'm the killer in the write-ups, and there's plenty of examples of where they aren't quite right.

 

That said, if Tales is a townie I know I'm for the chop. It would also confirm that Zell's a mafioso, as he's a roleblocker, he hasn't said much except to come into the thread and cast the final vote on Tales (which makes sense for the mafia to do if he's good - they want to kill a goodie before the townies change their minds) etc. Then again if he's evil....

 

I just with Peeps would get in here. And Tales would answer my question: he's viewed the thread enough times. Him not answering leads me to suspect he's a mafia member. If a townie under suspicion asked a mafia member a question such as that after they knew they were lynched, whatever they said would help the townie clear himself. Better for them to keep quiet and say nothing. It makes sense in my head anyway, but I know I'm innocent and it's making me see the game from an entirely different POV from most other people who think I'm guilty. It's pretty interesting tbh.

[heroicjanitor]

I might feel more comfortable going after Cube instead today.

 

If we think this is the first time that the parrot has killed then it is likely because his non-kill power is less useful than the other powers the mafia have. Thus it may be better to kill someone else.

 

If the parrot rarely kills his non-kill power is probably more useful than the others.

 

Nintendohnut isn't behaving like a mafia, he was attacking Dazz when he could have gone after someone else(everyone is under suspicion). A less active member would surely have been killed with all of that write-up switching, looks like the mafia picked the wrong person to use it on :p Assuming Tales is the mafia parrot of course, then I don't think there is much doubt that Nintendohnut is good.

 

... One-legged man killed on night 1. Either this is long john silver or nintendohnut, going by the pirates we have left.

 

MadDog was revealed to be the killer that night by a tracker. More proof of write-up tampering.

[The Peeps]

Majority has been reached

 

Votes

 

Tales (6): Jonnas, Cube, Nintendohnut, HeroicJanitor, Zell

Nintendohnut (3): mr-paul, Tales, ReZourceman

 

The feathered pirate could see its time was up. The other pirates had finally acknowledged its existence and they were not pleased. Polly did the only sensible thing and flew as far away from the ship as possible.

 

Tales has left the ship. He was Polly the Parrot, mutinous to The Captain

 

Night 7 starts now

 

Night phase will end at 2pm Saturday.

 

 

9 Pirates Remaining:

Cube

HeroicJanitor

Jayseven

Jonnas

mr-paul

Nintendohnut

ReZourceman

The Fish

Zell

Diageo

MadDog

Dannyboy-the-Dane

mr-paul

Tellyn

Aqui1a

Ellmeister

Rummy

Dazz

Sméagol

Tales

 

Majority is 5

[Sméagol]

Fuck off Automerge