MadDog Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 That's the thing, we don't know if they're good or bad. Best to do what Cube said and just work it out ourselves.
Raining_again Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 I suppose if no-one else has any other info to go on, we might as well give this a shot.. Dannyboythedane...got anything to say for yourself?
MoogleViper Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 Off-topic: Will you be punishing inactives?
ReZourceman Posted August 19, 2010 Author Posted August 19, 2010 Off-topic: Will you be punishing inactives? Yes I shall ~eventually~. Unless they go away ala dan-likes-trees and (I think Ell is still away?)
Gizmo Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 Alright since nobody else has anything... I was told last night that Ellmeister was evil. The reason I'm a bit wary is that investigative roles that just give the alignment and nothing else tend to be a bit unreliable. Like, the mafia don usually appears good under investigation, or I might be a dumb cop who gets it all backwards. But I guess the only way to find out is to test it, so with that in mind... Vote: Ellmeister
MadDog Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 Hmm...if he turns out good, then at least we know everyone elses alignment you investigate. Vote:Ellmeister
Rummy Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 Are you sure Gizmo? That's a serious accusation to throw. I understand it's early days, but what's your general power and how does it confirm him as evil? Or is it a straightforward investigative and then a straightforward answer?
Gizmo Posted August 19, 2010 Posted August 19, 2010 It seems its a straightforward choose a target - see their alignment. But it only works every 2nd night.
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Yes, Raining, I am the double vote. I see no point in trying to hide it as I would be discovered quite fast, anyway. However, I am most definitely one of the townsfolk, and I'm going to use Rummy as proof that a double vote is definitely not just a mafia ability. Anyway, if Gizmo got the result that Ellmeister is evil, I say we go for it. It's the only sure-shot way to figure out if Gizmo's ability works. Vote: Ellmeister
Nintendohnut Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 A warning to whoever it was decided I was the first to die: I will find you. And in the next mafia game, I will kill you. Mostly: BALLS! Will have to wait til the next one now. I was so interested to find out the outcome of my power Ah well
ReZourceman Posted August 20, 2010 Author Posted August 20, 2010 Vote : Ellmeister - 5 - Gizmo, MadDog, Dannyboy-the-Dane, Mundi 19 Players. Majority is 10. CoolnessBears Cube Dannyboy-the-Dane dan-likes-trees Dyson Ellmeister Gizmo MadDog Marcamillian martinist MoogleViper Mundi Paj Meen Ah Raining_again Rummy SPAMBOT4000 Tales Tellyn Zell
Cube Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 If it is only every other night then it would seem unfair for it to be a bad cop role. Vote: Elm.
Rummy Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Yes, Raining, I am the double vote. I see no point in trying to hide it as I would be discovered quite fast, anyway. However, I am most definitely one of the townsfolk, and I'm going to use Rummy as proof that a double vote is definitely not just a mafia ability. Anyway, if Gizmo got the result that Ellmeister is evil, I say we go for it. It's the only sure-shot way to figure out if Gizmo's ability works. Vote: Ellmeister But in that game everyone started off saying that it was a mafia power to have, it's a bit of a false dichotomy to just be saying 'Oo, it's definitely good now because it was last time!' when last time, no one believed me! I will however, once more believe you...for now. Do you by any chance happen to be Shiny, also? Given what Gizmo's saying and that people are agreeing, I guess I'm gonna go with Vote: Ellmeister.
MoogleViper Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Stop voting for ellmeister. I know for absolute fact that he's not evil.
MoogleViper Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Me and him are partners. We can target people and see who they target. For example last night I discovered that you (paj) targeted nobody. And from the write up I'm guessing you're the mainly white pokemon. A light purple Pokemon followed a mainly white Pokemon but it never left its hut.
Cube Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Me and him are partners. We can target people and see who they target. Can't one of you be evil, though?
MoogleViper Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Not according to my pm. And we both received the same pm with both our roles written in it.
Gizmo Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 I'm sticking with my vote...I need to know what my power is like, and you could easily be a mafioso defending a teammate.
Cube Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 Not according to my pm. And we both received the same pm with both our roles written in it. I'm wondering is ReZ is clever/imaginative enough to have a role where your partner is actually evil (i.e. he gets a second PM with his real role).
MoogleViper Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 I'm sticking with my vote...I need to know what my power is like, and you could easily be a mafioso defending a teammate. Ok so if ell gets lynched then we should all vote for you.
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted August 20, 2010 Posted August 20, 2010 But in that game everyone started off saying that it was a mafia power to have, it's a bit of a false dichotomy to just be saying 'Oo, it's definitely good now because it was last time!' when last time, no one believed me! I will however, once more believe you...for now. Do you by any chance happen to be Shiny, also? Given what Gizmo's saying and that people are agreeing, I guess I'm gonna go with Vote: Ellmeister. Now, I never said it is definitely good now because it was last time. That's silly, I agree. I simply said that suspecting me because a double vote is usually a mafia power doesn't hold water because, as demonstrated, double votes are not necessarily a mafia power. Anyway, Moogle's intervention complicates the case a bit. I really don't see why Gizmo would be lying as he would be found out soon enough if he pulled this trick more than once. Of course, if he is mafia, he might just try to score two kills this way, one "mistake" to figure out if his power works, and then a lie in the end when we think we can trust him and he makes us kill off the last townie (I did that myself in a previous game when I had gained the town's trust). A good/evil partnership is an intricate role, but ReZ did say he would spice things up this time around. I don't really know what to think. For now I'm holding on to my vote. I'm willing to take that risk.
Recommended Posts