Ellmeister Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 Seeing as we have held a few games now, could we post some sort of blacklist/ acknowledgement of who the inactives are?
jayseven Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 dannyboy; but doesn't teh rest of my post hit the point? :P smaller games, fewer games; boom.
Eenuh Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 I think people should be smart enough to take a break themselves if they have gotten tired of the games. I've taken a break recently as I knew I would be too busy to pay attention to it. Plus three games at once is too many, so I only sign up in one game. If you think about what you can handle, it'll make these games more fun again I think. Don't sign up for all of them if it's going to be too much. If there's a new game coming up of which I like the theme, I'm in!
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 dannyboy; but doesn't teh rest of my post hit the point? :P smaller games, fewer games; boom. Sure, but you all keep saying it's the inactives' own responsibility to not sign up when clearly people still keep signing up and becoming inactive.
Diageo Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 Sure, but you all keep saying it's the inactives' own responsibility to not sign up when clearly people still keep signing up and becoming inactive. So to combat that, you think we should all not play any games, and then the inactives will just stop joining games?
Mr-Paul Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 Personally, I don't think we can blame inactivity in mafia games totally on there being lots of them going on. There are lots of factors, including how good the GM is at keeping to deadlines; the style of the game (Dazz and Diageo's games currently running are extremely different to each other); how good a start the mafia gets off to - if they get killed quickly they'll become inactive to keep low; how quickly the most active players get killed/voted off and also how well the actual roles suit the players who have them. I think it's also good for a mafia game for there to be lots of confusion/false results/switchers. The most fun I have in mafia games is going after Nintendohnut genuinely believing he is evil even if he isn't! And I admit that I do prefer to be mafia than a townie. Being in a neutral mafia was good because I got no real suspicion :P There's no reason to sign up to a mafia if you don't think you can participate much. There is a trend of certain players who always sign up, post once a day, every other day and last a lot longer than people who would generally be active. It annoyed me in the pokémafia, the one where us as the mafia were close to winning and suddenly several townie inactives appeared and won after doing NOTHING all game, not even sending PMs some nights. I guess that's part of the excitement of it, but there's my analysis of the mafia game situation :P PARANOIA! THATS WHAT THE GAMES NEED! PLENTY OF PARANOIA!
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted February 20, 2011 Posted February 20, 2011 So to combat that, you think we should all not play any games, and then the inactives will just stop joining games? Nope, I expect inactive people to gain interest again. We saw the mafia games die out last time, seemingly because people got an overdose. Personally, I don't think we can blame inactivity in mafia games totally on there being lots of them going on. There are lots of factors, including how good the GM is at keeping to deadlines; the style of the game (Dazz and Diageo's games currently running are extremely different to each other); how good a start the mafia gets off to - if they get killed quickly they'll become inactive to keep low; how quickly the most active players get killed/voted off and also how well the actual roles suit the players who have them. I think it's also good for a mafia game for there to be lots of confusion/false results/switchers. The most fun I have in mafia games is going after Nintendohnut genuinely believing he is evil even if he isn't! And I admit that I do prefer to be mafia than a townie. Being in a neutral mafia was good because I got no real suspicion :P There's no reason to sign up to a mafia if you don't think you can participate much. There is a trend of certain players who always sign up, post once a day, every other day and last a lot longer than people who would generally be active. It annoyed me in the pokémafia, the one where us as the mafia were close to winning and suddenly several townie inactives appeared and won after doing NOTHING all game, not even sending PMs some nights. I guess that's part of the excitement of it, but there's my analysis of the mafia game situation :P PARANOIA! THATS WHAT THE GAMES NEED! PLENTY OF PARANOIA! I agree. I think we need some games that are not as text-heavy and with very active roles that will get some action and suspense going. I certainly enjoy the two current games, but they're heavier and slower which might decrease people's interest.
Dyson Posted February 21, 2011 Posted February 21, 2011 Bare Bones II is being written up as we speak, expect a signup thread in a few days : peace:
jayseven Posted February 21, 2011 Posted February 21, 2011 Sure, but you all keep saying it's the inactives' own responsibility to not sign up when clearly people still keep signing up and becoming inactive. Oi quit lumping me in with the others :P Not once did I mention anything about teh inactives!
chairdriver Posted February 21, 2011 Posted February 21, 2011 Awoke unusually early this morning, and planned a 12 player mafia as a joke thing.
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted February 21, 2011 Posted February 21, 2011 Oi quit lumping me in with the others :P Not once did I mention anything about teh inactives! Sorry! It wasn't directed at you specifically, just the ones whom it concerned. : peace:
The Peeps Posted February 22, 2011 Posted February 22, 2011 Can you stick my End of the World mafia to the end of the list? Name may change but that's the theme at least.
ReZourceman Posted February 22, 2011 Author Posted February 22, 2011 For you The Peeps - I can do anything. Currently active Mafia Games DEATH NOTE Mafia (Diageo) Harry Potter and the Dark Mark Mafia (Dazz) Currently Signing up None Signing Up Soon Bare Bones Mafia II (By Dyson) DC Comincs Mafia (By Paj Meen Ah) TBC Mafia (By Dannyboy-the-Dane) Mafiawesome: Lucid Drift Mafia (By Jayseven) Pokemafia 9 : Red and Blue Mafia (By ReZourceman) Super Smash Bros Brawl 2 : Rematch (By Diageo) Heroes Mafia (By The Peeps) The Robot Mafia (By Jonnas) The 007 Mafia (By Nintendohnut) High School TV Series Mafia (By Tales) End of the World Mafia (By The Peeps)
Esequiel Posted February 25, 2011 Posted February 25, 2011 I never even knew all these games were going on! The scoreboard is legendary, Im amazed that my old sci-fi game is scored aswell I'm working or roles for a new game as we speak
The Peeps Posted March 2, 2011 Posted March 2, 2011 I think someone should make a sign-up thread :P not long left for the current games.. well the harry potter one at least. Hard to tell how far away we are in the deathnote mafia.
ReZourceman Posted March 2, 2011 Author Posted March 2, 2011 Bare Bones II is being written up as we speak, expect a signup thread in a few days : peace: ^^^^^^^^ Although a few days has digivolved into 9 days.
ReZourceman Posted March 4, 2011 Author Posted March 4, 2011 C'maaaaannnn Dyssoooonnnszzzz. HP is about to end, we'll be on one almost done Mafia with not a huge amount of "active" players. Paj/Danny, whats the status of yours?
Paj! Posted March 4, 2011 Posted March 4, 2011 Hmm. Well ages ago I started thinking about DC Mafia, with fairly revolutionary/innovative/brand new gameplay[/hype] but then never really settled down to plan it out thouroughly. One of the reasons I started playing in less games is Uni, and I'm still there so yeah. I'll think about it.
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted March 4, 2011 Posted March 4, 2011 I've told you numerous times to throw me to the bottom of the list, or even just remove me completely, since I have absolutely zilch at the moment. I wanted to be put on the list when I thought I'd make another mafia fairly soon after the Colour one, but I lost the mafia-maker drive and haven't got it back yet. When/if I get my arse in gear to make another mafia, I'll let you know.
jayseven Posted March 5, 2011 Posted March 5, 2011 Alright. Well if you give me a day, I can concoct stuff. Just not this day. I'm busy 'til thursday :P But yes! I can pull stuff.
ReZourceman Posted March 5, 2011 Author Posted March 5, 2011 Okay cool. Does anyone have a problem with the below reshuffling? Currently active Mafia Games DEATH NOTE Mafia (Diageo) Harry Potter and the Dark Mark Mafia (Dazz) Currently Signing up None Signing Up Soon Mafiawesome: Lucid Drift Mafia (By Jayseven) Bare Bones Mafia II (By Dyson) Pokemafia 9 : Red and Blue Mafia (By ReZourceman) DC Comincs Mafia (By Paj Meen Ah) Super Smash Bros Brawl 2 : Rematch (By Diageo) Heroes Mafia (By The Peeps) The Robot Mafia (By Jonnas) The 007 Mafia (By Nintendohnut) High School TV Series Mafia (By Tales) End of the World Mafia (By The Peeps) TBC Mafia (By Dannyboy-the-Dane) Oh...but if HP or DN finishes and no one else is ready then I'm just gonna go.....
Nintendohnut Posted March 5, 2011 Posted March 5, 2011 I am also ready to go I think, so if we're having a massive "Oh shit there's no mafias" moment i can go for it. That said previous inactives will probably not be welcomed (because I'm a harsh bastard but also because I want my game to keep the pace and interest levels up). I also have like 20 roles but I know I probably won't need them all [/random thoughts]
ReZourceman Posted March 5, 2011 Author Posted March 5, 2011 *Uncontrollably lets out a small squeal*
Jonnas Posted March 5, 2011 Posted March 5, 2011 Hmm... I just noticed have like 14 roles in the robot mafia, and 13 for Gentlemen's II. Add Gentlemen's II to the list, ReZ.
Recommended Posts