ReZourceman Posted December 31, 2007 Author Posted December 31, 2007 The rest was pointless fighting with no plot. Yeah...and it was awesome fighting. But awesome fighting alone a film does not maketh.
Shorty Posted December 31, 2007 Posted December 31, 2007 Oh c'mon. You can't rate every film on the same thing. Do you really always go to the cinema expecting awesome storytelling, a twist, an involving and deep plot, clever between-the-lines points? 300 was about the CG, the catchphrases, the slow-motion, the sheer size of the opposition, the manliness, the blood and swords and stabbing. Some films are meant to be enjoyed on a level of pure entertainment and action. Then you have to narrow down, without straying outside the confines of that genre, the ones that do it well. For example, Die Hard 4.0 tried too hard and wound up woefully generic as action goes, with none of the awesome wit and edge-of-your-seat tension the first three films had. 300, it's not the world's smartest film, but you have to rate it on how it lives up to your expectations. If you thought it was going to be stylish and gory action from toe to hair-ends, you couldn't be disappointed. If you thought it was going to suck because it had no character evolution or drama, you shouldn't have bothered watching it in the first place. Not all movies are meant to carry you away on a dreamy adventure. Some are there just to blow you away with special effects, or make you laugh, or scare you or whatever.
Shino Posted December 31, 2007 Posted December 31, 2007 And honour, don't forget the honour. 300 manages to be a emotive movie without a deep story, but it has enough to make you feel what they wanted you to feel.
ReZourceman Posted December 31, 2007 Author Posted December 31, 2007 Oh c'mon. You can't rate every film on the same thing. Do you really always go to the cinema expecting awesome storytelling, a twist, an involving and deep plot, clever between-the-lines points? 300 was about the CG, the catchphrases, the slow-motion, the sheer size of the opposition, the manliness, the blood and swords and stabbing. Some films are meant to be enjoyed on a level of pure entertainment and action. Then you have to narrow down, without straying outside the confines of that genre, the ones that do it well. For example, Die Hard 4.0 tried too hard and wound up woefully generic as action goes, with none of the awesome wit and edge-of-your-seat tension the first three films had. 300, it's not the world's smartest film, but you have to rate it on how it lives up to your expectations. If you thought it was going to be stylish and gory action from toe to hair-ends, you couldn't be disappointed. If you thought it was going to suck because it had no character evolution or drama, you shouldn't have bothered watching it in the first place. Not all movies are meant to carry you away on a dreamy adventure. Some are there just to blow you away with special effects, or make you laugh, or scare you or whatever. Couldn't agree more with this.
Gizmo Posted December 31, 2007 Posted December 31, 2007 Thanks for the spoilers. Well, you ruined 300 for me!
Babooo Posted December 31, 2007 Posted December 31, 2007 300 is awesome. Simple as. My brother just got the DVD in the post and can't wait to rewatch it soon!! One thing I'm curious about is why people love Knocked Up so much. I fucking hate this movie. Didn't think it was funny at all and can't see what the fuss was all about tbh. Superbad, on the other hand, was much much better! Agreed with that choice!
ReZourceman Posted December 31, 2007 Author Posted December 31, 2007 One thing I'm curious about is why people love Knocked Up so much. I fucking hate this movie. Didn't think it was funny at all and can't see what the fuss was all about tbh. Its just greatness. Like I keep seeing the adverts, and the bit where he screams in the cinema is just friggin hilarious. Visually lol funny. Can't wait to rewatch it, and the extras, I will probably do so tomorrow on New Years Noon.
Goron_3 Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 You rated 300? Was there actually a point to that film? The best part was when it was showing up grow up in the mountains. The rest was pointless fighting with no plot. 300 is an incredible film. It's so beautiful it's ridiculous. Seeing it in 1080p blue-ray on a 50inch HD set makes me wet (more than once too).
Shorty Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 And honour, don't forget the honour. 300 manages to be a emotive movie without a deep story, but it has enough to make you feel what they wanted you to feel. Damn I knew I was missing one word
Oxigen_Waste Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 I now ask myself, does this thread have a "plot"? I mean, no offense ReZ, but what the fuck?
darksnowman Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 I voted for Rocky Balboa and its nowhere to be seen.
Oxigen_Waste Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 Hm... I voted for No Country For Old Men. Wonder how many votes besides mine it got. Apparently none.
Solo Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 I think your scores are way to generous on some but.. Here are mine I saw 42 films. These are all on first impressions: Grindhouse - 9/10 The Bourne Ultimatum - 8/10 Once - 8/10 Blood Diamond - 8/10 300 - 8/10 Ratatouille 8/10 Letters From Iwo Jima - 8/10 Flags of Our Fathers - 8/10 Knocked Up - 8/10 Superbad - 8/10 Zodiac - 7/10 Atonement - 7/10 Sunshine - 7/10 The Fountain - 7/10 I Am Legend - 7/10 30 Days of Night - 7/10 Rocky Balboa - 7/10 The Illusionist - 7/10 Beowulf - 6/10 Curse of the Golden Flower - 6/10 Harry Potter - 6/10 Spider-Man 3 - 6/10 28 Weeks Later - 6/10 1408 - 6/10 Transformers - 6/10 Hot Fuzz - 6/10 Run, Fat Boy, Run - 6/10 Eastern Promises - 6/10 The Ex - 6/10 Die Hard 4.0 - 5/10 The Simpsons - 5/10 TMNT - 5/10 Smokin’ Aces - 5/10 Blades of Glory - 5/10 Hostel Part II - 5/10 Severance - 5/10 The Number 23 - 5/10 Fantastic 4 2 - 4/10 Saw IV - 4/10 PotC: At World’s End - 4/10 The Golden Compass - 4/10 Paradise Lost - 2/10 I haven't seen No Country For Old Men yet but I've heard nothing but good things.
ReZourceman Posted January 1, 2008 Author Posted January 1, 2008 Hm... I voted for No Country For Old Men. Wonder how many votes besides mine it got. Apparently none. Its not even out here, but Im sure if more people had seen it, it would of gotten some ratings. I cannot friggin wait to see it.
Goron_3 Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 I voted for Rocky Balboa and its nowhere to be seen. I know the feeling lol. Wicked film imo. My fav film this year probably apart from Hot Fuzz (which i saw on valentines day haha) and Superbad!
jayseven Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 ... Maan, this thread sucks. I don't remember voting the first time through, but I'd vote for superbad if I could now. I've not seen most of the films you've seen ReZ, but I disagree how you can rate films that you never want to see again 7+, films that you thought were just "ok". the 5 is there for a reason!
ReZourceman Posted January 1, 2008 Author Posted January 1, 2008 ... Maan, this thread sucks. I don't remember voting the first time through, but I'd vote for superbad if I could now. I've not seen most of the films you've seen ReZ, but I disagree how you can rate films that you never want to see again 7+, films that you thought were just "ok". the 5 is there for a reason! Just cos' I dont want to see a film again doesnt mean its a bad film. It means its a good film that doesnt have a lot of re-watchability, or just that I wish not to see again.
sarah♥ Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 Superbad is the funniest film I've ever seen, ooo and Transformers is awesome
Slaggis Posted January 1, 2008 Posted January 1, 2008 Out of all of the 2007 movies I've seen in the cinema, I'd have to change my vote now and go for I Am Legend, it was great fun to watch.
ReZourceman Posted January 2, 2010 Author Posted January 2, 2010 What the fuck was I thinking back then?
Shorty Posted January 2, 2010 Posted January 2, 2010 What the fuck was I thinking back then? I don't know, but I know we have rules against bumping super old threads on purpose.
Recommended Posts