dan-likes-trees Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Int-er-est-ing. Well my current feeling is that either Nintendohut or Cube are Mafia. Guess we shall find out soon!
Cube Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 But you seem to be after me purely because I'm one of the more active people here. Int-er-est-ing. Well my current feeling is that either Nintendohut or Cube are Mafia. Guess we shall find out soon! I personally don't think that 'nut is mafia, he's just spending too much time looking at the wrong person and twisting some poor facts to suit his reasoning - for example, stating that no steel Pokémon have appeared in the write-up. The write-up mainly says sizes or colours.
MadDog Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 I'm with Nintendohnut, if we lynch Cube and he's good, we lose one townie. If he's mafia there's a few others who would suddenly turn really suspicious, I think they are pretty good odds.
Nintendohnut Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Int-er-est-ing. Well my current feeling is that either Nintendohut or Cube are Mafia. Guess we shall find out soon! Well if you think it's one of us or the other, why not vote for Cube today (as he closest to the lynch anyway) and then if he's not mafia you can follow your other thought and lynch me tomorrow? I'm not sure why you're voting for Jimbob if you think it's either me or Cube? But you seem to be after me purely because I'm one of the more active people here. I had a look through my posts and can't find any point where I said that. As I explained, I was saying the fact that someone talks is not a reason to keep someone alive if there's evidence they're bad. I never said vote for Cube because he talks...
Rummy Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 LIES! Last night I was roleblocked, and although this may be down to some 'confusion', according to Cube whatever happened to me should have been transferred to him. So why would I have been roleblocked? It seems ridiculous that Maddog would be able to roleblock two people in one night as it makes Cube's power redundant. I strongly advise we vote Cube. The fact this steel pokemon hasn't appeared in any of the write-ups even in a 'watching' role is way to suspicious. Cube, to prove me wrong tell me how you know you were roleblocked last night, and give some details about what happened, then MAYBE I'll believe you. At the moment I think you're trying to wriggle out of a hole. Tbh, I thought it through before this post and came to the conclusion Cube follows with. If he takes the hit for someone else, but the hit he takes is a roleblocking, then it becomes paradoxical, surely its easy like that? Don't get me wrong though, I'm still keeping my vote on Cube. If he turns out to be mafia, then yay, if he turns out to be town, then I know a few people I'm definitely gunning for next.
Jimbob Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 I'm sticking with my vote, you never know it could always be the good guys that are least expected to do these sorts of things.
dan-likes-trees Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Well if you think it's one of us or the other, why not vote for Cube today (as he closest to the lynch anyway) and then if he's not mafia you can follow your other thought and lynch me tomorrow? I'm not sure why you're voting for Jimbob if you think it's either me or Cube? Just cause he's one of the more active ones / seems to have an idea of what's going on, much like yourself, so would be more valuable to keep. Nonetheless, you do raise a good point so vote change to Cube
ReZourceman Posted August 11, 2010 Author Posted August 11, 2010 15 players: Majority is 8 Cube dan-likes-trees DannyboyTheDane Diageo Dyson Eenuh Ellmeister Gizmo Ganepark32 Jimbob Jonnas MadDog Nintendohnut Raining_again Rummy Vote : Cube - 7 - Gizmo, MadDog, Nintendohnut, Ganepark32, Rummy, dan-likes-trees. Vote : Jimbob - 3 - Jonnas, Eenuh, Diageo Vote : Jonnas - 1 - Jimbob
Cube Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 I had a look through my posts and can't find any point where I said that. The very start of your "suspicion" was from me commenting on the kills that night, which IMO is mandatory from the first few people who see the thread. So from what I see, you're picking on me because I'm the first one to see the thread. I have told the truth about my powers and that I'm a steel Pokémon, which goes against other theories about the mafia.
Nintendohnut Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 The very start of your "suspicion" was from me commenting on the kills that night, which IMO is mandatory from the first few people who see the thread. So from what I see, you're picking on me because I'm the first one to see the thread. I have told the truth about my powers and that I'm a steel Pokémon, which goes against other theories about the mafia. When did I pick on you speaking first? Find the post where I said that because I don't remember it at all. The reasons I'm suspicious are 1) you apparently haven't appeared in any write-ups 2) you claimed that you were roleblocked last night and then decided you weren't, either way the power you described causes problems with your explanation 3) you've given only a vague description of your character (a steel pokemon that's quite new) and as the only 'theory' about the mafia is that they're electric, based on the death of one mafia member, it doesn't really prove anything.
Cube Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 1) I'm sorry, it was Gizmo that started that. 2) I said I wasn't sure in my first post about it. I've since explained why. 3) I'm a Pokémon currently known as Gear or Giaru.
Diageo Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Well since we are so close, and no one seems to want to vote for Jimbob so that road will lead us nowhere. Changevote: Cube. Even though I don't think it is him. Final nail in the coffin.
ReZourceman Posted August 11, 2010 Author Posted August 11, 2010 15 players: Majority of 8 has been reached. Cube dan-likes-trees DannyboyTheDane Diageo Dyson Eenuh Ellmeister Gizmo Ganepark32 Jimbob Jonnas MadDog Nintendohnut Raining_again Rummy Vote : Cube - 8 - Gizmo, MadDog, Nintendohnut, Ganepark32, Rummy, dan-likes-trees, Diageo. Vote : Jimbob - 2 - Jonnas, Eenuh. Vote : Jonnas - 1 - Jimbob ------------ The town ascended on Cube, whom some had suspected was evil and others had been more stubborn. Cube is dead. He was Magneton, the evil magnetising Pokemon. He was a member of the mafia. NIGHT FOUR. Get your PMs in now. Day phase will begin at 7:00pm on 12th August, or when I receive the last PM if that is sooner.
Diageo Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 I thought talking wasn't allowed during the night phase.
ReZourceman Posted August 11, 2010 Author Posted August 11, 2010 I thought talking wasn't allowed during the night phase. An "I Told You So" isn't going to do any harm. Frankly you folks can talk as much as you want during night, as long as you don't touch on the game I don't mind at all. Incidentally I've got half the PMs already. This has potential to be a quick night phase if others follow suit.
Diageo Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Can someone explain exactly how the night phase works for the mafia? I've always wondered.
Ellmeister Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Whilst this may all be a ploy to make people believe you aren't mafia. Mafia can talk whenever they want with each other as they know who is who. So they can co-ordinate their targets. That's all.
ReZourceman Posted August 11, 2010 Author Posted August 11, 2010 Jeebus cist, that was quick. I'm only awaiting one PM now.
Ellmeister Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 PM them telling them everyone is just waiting for them?
Diageo Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Whilst this may all be a ploy to make people believe you aren't mafia. Mafia can talk whenever they want with each other as they know who is who. So they can co-ordinate their targets. That's all. Who decides who dies after everybody votes? Who decides who kills who? Is there a big conversation type chat space where everyone talks or are people PM-ing each other little opinions and such?
ReZourceman Posted August 11, 2010 Author Posted August 11, 2010 PM them telling them everyone is just waiting for them? I don't want to give anything away, so I'm just acknowledging that I've seen this post.
Ellmeister Posted August 11, 2010 Posted August 11, 2010 Who decides who dies after everybody votes? Who decides who kills who?Is there a big conversation type chat space where everyone talks or are people PM-ing each other little opinions and such? In past games people have set up a chat space on a free forum. So yeah as I said they can co-ordinate together who to target and do what they want with their powers. and ReZ...wtf is that supposed to mean?
Recommended Posts