Apparently the mafia aren't allowed to kill unconscious people, so go to sleep at night you damn insomniacs.
I'm still a bit skeptical but The Peeps could have enjoyed the same "services" as the handsome guy.
Here are my reasons for not trusting Diageo:
He is a doctor, and would know of The Peeps illness, describing "how they knew". Not you personally diageo but the doctor character so don't ask how you could have known.
He came out happy meaning he could have obtained information on you, or you could have given him some medicine. Medicine which didn't work.
You have such a vague description of what it is your power does, which makes me think you are avoiding committing to one power.