I love how it looks like he is actually saying Tales in that second gif :p But yeah I thought he was neutral, a very clever ruse actually. He can't say who he targeted either.
Not as awesome as Jonnas but here's an explanation.
If two of these are mafia, then there is one mafia amongst me, jay, Diageo and Jonnas.
Since there is one mafia amongst me, jay, Diageo and Jonnas, the 2nd mafia in this list must be Tales.
Change Vote: Tales