I think we always expect too much from launch line ups, they're rarely brilliant.
The Xbox One's though is better I will admit but neither really have that big game to show it off. Xbox will be closest with Dead Rising 3 I guess. Its a shame that Infamous wont have been finished in time, every account of that Ive read has said its probably the most "next gen" looking game out there so far.
Still, I think Watch Dogs and Battlefield 4 will be fine for me, along with whatever PSN games I decide to buy on the day.
As for Serebii....does anyone really care what he says at this point? The guy just seems to have become a bit of a joke.