Sheikah

Exactly! And how long does a post take? Barely any time really. That's why, unless someone literally has no internet connection or extremely mitigating circumstances, I always cast a critical eye on people claiming they can't post.

Sorry, I never accept personal reasons despite how true they may be. It's too open to abuse. Plus I personally don't believe making 3-4 posts a day with useful info takes particularly much time.

Rather than just post a list of my suspects I'll say why they're there. towniest Sheikah EEVILMURRAY - Very genuine, forward with character information. bob - he's new, he doesn't half seem to know what he's doing. This could be a brilliant ruse but somehow I don't think Jimbob would have made someone who didn't know what they were doing Mafia. Magnus - I think he's town, but can't put him near the top because of the amount of links to Jonnas' death and being the only one to claim he was controlled. DuD - Would have been higher, but naturally accusing me triggers an instinctive part of me that makes me think the accusation may not be genuine. Still, probably town. mr-paul: Compared to last game he is acting pretty town. Dannyboy - I'll be honest, I'm not familiar with his play style as the few games we've both been in he hasn't been very active. Could be either. Moogle - I genuinely have little to say either way on him. Cube - I can't put my finger on this, something about his role seems incredibly weak (just protecting against roleblocks). Could be hiding something. If anyone was neutral I think it'd be him. Rummy - he seemed to eager to protect someone for little reason. Could be wrong here. Yvonne - very quiet compared to normal. There's also the issue with the second Lister that could relate to his role. Plus points for the suspect list, you might climb higher on my list yet. Jon Dedede - could be a double voter and hasn't told us this. Nintendohnut - naturally. Really, I don't trust him and I think Jimbob probably put him on the Mafia's team when you all idiotically claimed because he entered late he must be town. Animal - hasn't said a word in days. Apparently everyone is fine with this. Scummiest Second post: Dohnut hadn't replied when I started posting so didn't know he had a double vote before I made the list.

It could be argued? Are you a machine or a computer?

Why can't he have a double vote? I don't see why any particular character should have a double vote.

People are actually coming to my way of thinking though, that you can't truly have 'nothing', so there's no moral crusade for me to try and push onto people here. :p In terms of out of character Yvonne is being a lot quieter than I am, so I don't really see an issue. I've no problem mentioning that my character is not AI or machine, and I've said before that I think a possible plot could be an AI takeover.

I completely agree actually. Vote:Yvonne. This should get you talking. Come on people.

Oh and you got me all excited, where's this announcement then!

Meh, crappy month.

He who does not comprehend meta does not do well. People are creatures of habit, as best they try they to act differently they will almost always give something away at some point. Understanding the playstyle of others is really important.

True but there are two things that we shouldn't forget: 1.Some people like Jimbob usually tell the truth about most things even when Mafia 2. He's new to Mafia games and probably isn't confident enough to lie even if he wanted to. On evidence (or circumstantial evidence) I'd say there's strong links to him being scum. But based on character analysis I'd say he's not scum. I'd never lynch someone who I thought behaved town but had evidence against them.

I'll play.

Yeah, now they've offered toast a few times it is somewhat obvious. I don't think they're town based on what has happened so far but I don't have proof either way. It's possible that given the toaster is always asking people for toast in the show that he could offer toast to people at night, with the potential for them to refuse.

If it's not Magnus then who? Magnus it's pretty obvious why you avoided telling us you were the chef, which is why I'm pretty surprised you just told us at all. The way you're behaving is pretty town, and I like to think I'm a good judge of character. Now we know you're the cook though there's more to link you to Jonas; @Animal speak up, you're being pretty quiet.

Unmerge...

So I take 3DS? Shame. Vita would lap this up.

I'm guessing you mean either Animal or Dohnut then.

Just noticed this. I don't think it's Yvonne either, who I'm pretty sure is town. I thought it was Cube initially from his youtube bid, unless you have a stronger lead. I'd say the chef is probably our strongest lynch candidate along with Magnus.

I did a pumpkin at the weekend and went to a good couple of parties, one of which was my sister's which started out at our family's home. I went for something a bit like Jack Skellington: And our front garden...got some funny looks:

I think it's very easy to lie about what you're saying though. Despite all the people who saw you, none saw you going on a date and no one has come forward as a second Lister. You walked away from where Jonnas was killed and claim not to remember. This is the kind of thing that probably isn't going to get any clearer from discussion. I'm going to ask now, whoever the Lister doppelganger is to come forward and corroborate the story. I'm not asking for any role details, just for someone to lend credibility to his account. Post is directed at @Magnus Peterson

It's possible, but was pretty overpowered in the last game I played (much to my pleasure), so I'm less inclined to believe it. My main issue here is that Jon claims to have seen you drinking with Lister and walking away from the crime scene and you say you witnessed none of it. Whoever was drinking with you could shed some more light on this - did he appear inebriated in your writeup, @ whoever drank with Magnus?

Magnus, you say you went on a date but Jon said he saw you walking away from the airlock, the place Jonnas was killed. You might want to start explaining.

I've also been thinking it could be Holly, with the plot being centred around an AI uprising (this idea of course heavily influenced by one of the recent new episodes). Last night I wasn't roleblocked and reached my target successfully. @Nintendohnut you're being quieter than usual and naturally I'll never trust you, purely because the moderators of these games have a sick fetish to continually pit us on opposing sides. Did you reach your target? Second post - bad timing, I see you'be posted now. But that post is pure filler.

Lynches are the way forward but too often people don't assess whether people are out of character, instead comparing people against their preconceived idea of a 'perfect' townie. In this case it's difficult because I don't have any idea what Magnus's behaviour is like.

It doesn't look like any new info is going to surface today. Magnus Peterson are you Magnus but on a different account? I'm a bit suspicious of you but then I'm not familiar with your posting style (as many weren't with my style when I started). I'll be keeping my eye on you anyhow. vote: No-one