Sheikah

Well that clears things up. You are probably Mafia, and he is probably town/neutral.

If someone has a triple vote I would purchase a hat and eat it. That seems way overpowered.

Ah the overcrowded Trafford centre - from Manchester city centre get the metrolink to Stretford and the connecting shuttle bus from there.

Can we afford a drunk nutcase who dooms us all? lol

You were good in the first game I played. Or maybe I was shit. I digress... I guess my answer to that is that we judge, all of us. Lack of contribution leads to suspicion, arguing, and often handing the info over anyway after all the arguing is done (see Jay).

Well that is a lie. For one, of has Daniel Radcliffe's face on it. /trollface

Not ignoring, I just found it odd that you were arguing against revealing stuff on one hand, and on the other asking me for information! Yup I have a win condition. I think most should, else that seems unbalanced to me. @Cube I think you are just bad at reading me. In Jimbob's Mafia you were totally barking up the wrong tree thinking I was scum and ended up totally wrong on who the scum team was. I'm exactly the same as I was there. I came here to chew gum and find scum. Looks like I'm all out of scum. ...... D'oh

My thought is that anyone saying I could be Mafia is either joking, lying or just inexperienced. I'm willing to bet that mr-paul can tell I'm town. I'm hoping that's because he's a good judge of character and not from being scum.

Yo I heard you like mentions so I put a mention in yo' mention in yo' mention*. You got any thoughts on the state of play? *It's no good. We've got to go deeper.

No there are not. There is almost no chance that I would have correctly come up with the information of whether you reached your target or not. It pains me that you simply don't get it. Both you and Dohnut have a terrible attitude towards information release - the belief that keeping everything to yourself while asking questions of others is an acceptable way to play. I have really asked for the bare minimum and demonstrated how such information is overwhelmingly more useful to town. So I really don't see what the issue is.

And how do Mafia know what roles were carried out given they rarely have tracking abilities? See, much more useful for town for the reasons I gave. Ehm, I don't follow. Mafia aren't likely to make shit up about who they targeted unless they know all trackers are dead or are feeling daring. So ya, silence is a better tactic for them if their night target could incriminate them Ha, nice try. Tell me why you are happy for people to get by, asking questions about others while staying tight lipped even about info which as I've demonstrated, is far more useful to town than Mafia? Also note that almost all info revealed could be considered useful to both towns yet revealing info is essential for a town win.

NB I never requested something so ridiculous as a tracker to dish out their targets. I am saying that there is no such thing as 'I got nothing'. Saying you reached your target is hardly going to give the Mafia advantage and will let us work out who is being roleblocked so hey ho we can work out the number of roleblockers/redirectors knocking about and who the most common targets are for roleblocking.

Jay you're being evasive and using far more words than necessary to make a point, as usual. As I said, there is always something you can say, even if it's 'I reached my target'. Knowing you reached a target means we know you weren't roleblocked. Even if you don't know whether you were successful or not due to lack of PM, this is useful to know. This info is more useful to town than Mafia.

That's right, not so neutral. Because I'm town. So tell me why you think it's fair to not co-operate in the slightest while other people are contributing?

Explain how you could possibly know all these things you keep saying after just a few days of play.

It's also possible that our only kill protector is our jailkeeper friend, which could kinda suck. Appreciated, from now on could you try to join in a bit more and not just when people call you out? :p

What the hell? You realise that there is a guy called Prez in The Wire and that the ReZ likening to the name was already done ages ago and no one did much about it? Why the sudden call for lynch? I haven't seen ReZ active properly in months in any sense. Although because I hate inactivity, talk NAOW beetch.

No one protecting you Peeps makes me think there might not be a protector, because you were a pretty obvious choice. :/

No, no, I never said this. It implies that they might be town or they might not be. The crucial things is that they say something you can scrutinise (Mafia wouldn't like this), or use to piece together facts. If you say nothing or a useless 'got nothing', there is nothing to scrutinise. This is not useful to town. Um, you know this to be untrue. Dedede has next to no presence and has what, 3 posts in his life? He's just sailing by and apparently you're fine with this. mmkay... I revealed I was jailkept N1, and whether or not I reached my targets or not for every night so far. I'm also the only person to try to get people not giving town-friendly responses to actually talk.

But you're obviously not going to role reveal yet so by that logic no one but information gatherers would have anything 'useful'. It's all useful, we can use this to piece stuff together. 'I got nothing' may as well be replaced with 'I'm possibly Mafia' or 'feigned activity post'.

@Jon Dedede your contribution has been next to nothing. Speak up.

Does your power not return info or do you were suspect you were roleblocked?

It's true that there's reason within this thread to trust you, but that could also be interpreted as 'so why isn't he dead yet?' sort of questioning in terms of the Mafia not picking up on it (most Mafia contain at least 1 competent player from my past experience). P.S. I'm not trying to be aggressive here, merely trying to eke out information so that we're not a few days down the line with next to no clue about anyone and about to be town killed. You're actually one of the better players here in terms of actual discussion contribution, DuD.

Is the night when you do nothing a cooldown of some sort to an ability? I only ask because Mafia members will occasionally not use an ability, instead opting to do something else more sinister. NB - note my qualm was with posts that state "I got nothing" - the very kind of post from which nothing, even subtle, can be discerned.