The Peeps Posted January 4, 2013 Author Posted January 4, 2013 (edited) @Sheikah has been removed from the game. He will not pass go, he will not collect £200. 8 players remain, majority is 5 Day Six is ongoing I hope my leniency hasn't ruined the game and we can still salvage things. I (obviously) don't like to remove people from my games but I guess this one did really break a role (more so than thanking which was still a cheap move and obviously shouldn't have been done - not a dig). If people want to discuss this, please do so in the general mafia thread. Preferably AFTER the game. Edited January 8, 2013 by The Peeps
Yvonne Posted January 4, 2013 Posted January 4, 2013 We should go ahead and vote Rummy so we can carry on with an unbroken game
Sheikah Posted January 4, 2013 Posted January 4, 2013 Fair enough @The Peeps, no hard feelings. I had fun.
Cube Posted January 4, 2013 Posted January 4, 2013 I suppose there's nothing else that we can do, then. Vote Rummy
Nintendohnut Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 I'm not sure about Rummy. @Rummy - can you point out the post where you were truth-serumed and answered questions about your role, please? If you're telling the truth about those posts, I'll believe you're telling the truth about your role and not vote for you. @EEVILMURRAY I have two questions for you: - Has your killed any other characters during this game? - Who have your targets been during this game's night phases?
DuD Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 I don't think its a case of being sure or not dohnut, I think its more the right thing to do.. Vote: Rummy I've got a question for Cube.. how sure were you about Sheikah's alignment? After yesterday's lynch im pretty sure he was mafia/mi6! How did the mafia know not to night kill MadDog even after he claimed to become an alignment investigator? surely he'd be top of their kill list? Sheikah was the one with all the info.. How easy would it be for him to give one of us info to gain our trust? it doesn't mean all that info wasn't already out and proud in the mafia forum! He even tried getting me lynched by sharing his incriminating evidence on me but keeping the evidence he had that cleared me to himself... that's pretty scummy. So yeah I want to know if your trust in him simply boils down to him having "trust" in you, because I think we're one Mafioso down.
Cube Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 My trust in him was from those codes he posted. He told me my information in one (he knew that I was a protector of some kind, hence why he trusted me), and information on you in another. So part of it is that he knew that I was a protector from night 1.
DuD Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 So he gains your trust by providing your info and you protect him each night meaning your not blocking their killer. Did he give you all my info including what cleared me or just what suited him?
Cube Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 It said - Your agent code - That you were a roleblocker - They you were Coldfinger's right hand man (I didn't realise this at first, but once someone else said it I realised it's what the code said) - He also said to not reveal this information unless you were dead.
Nintendohnut Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 Well, I don't think neturals are the 'mafia' in this game. Maddog was neutral, and his win condition was to be night-killed. That's not really a mafia win condition. I think that, unless we're right about Rummy, this is game over. And I'm not convinced that we're right about Rummy, because the votes on him stacked up so quickly based solely on the fact that Diageo claims he has the same role as Rummy so Rummy must be scum. We haven't even asked whether Diageo could be a mafioso If Rummy is MI6 that's awesome, and we've bought ourselves some time. If not, we've lost I think.
DuD Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 You've killed the game for me. Well done. I'm done too. Fuck people who want to play like that. I've requested either a removal from the game by Peeps, but in case it doesn't come - Vote:Rummy. The votes haven't stacked up on Rummy through what diageo has said.. I personally think diageo has the choice between roleblocker and silencer and is part of the mafia. The votes have stacked up as he's asked to be removed. Cube I've already explained my power.. yes I can end up roleblocking, but I am not a roleblocker. This info is already in the thread so I won't be going over it again.
Nintendohnut Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 But that's a stupid reason to vote him off. If he wants to be removed he can simply resign to Peeps. We don't need to waste a day phase voting for him. If we think Diageo is a silencer, why aren't we voting for him? That seems ridiculous. I get that Rummy is annoyed, and he absolutely should be - Sheikah went too far and basically cheated. However, that doesn't mean that the rest of use should waste the day phase by voting him off. He can PM Peeps and complain, as I'm sure he has done, and ask to be removed. Meanwhile, we can vote off the person we think is evil. It's fairly clear that Rummy isn't evil. The mafia wouldn't let him kill himself so late on, when they're so close to victory. This whole game has been fucked up by Sheikah. Cheers mate!
DuD Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 I posted my suspicions of diageo last day phase when Mr-paul was silenced, but a lot of people disagreed. I'll stick by my convictions then.. Vote: Diageo
Diageo Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 Other people have been silenced when I've role blocked other people. Just look through the thread instead of going off your baseless assumptions.
Sheikah Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 This whole game has been fucked up by Sheikah. Cheers mate! I would stay out of this as I've left but I find this highly hypocritical. You pretty much cheated yourself by answering people by thanking their posts in order to communicate when you were silenced. Peeps himself also said this was wrong, albeit obviously to a lesser degree than what I did. I can tell you for sure I wouldn't have done a thing had you not set some kind of a precedent. I'm not saying what I did was fine, just that people in glass houses shouldn't throw stones... Anyway...I hardly see how this has 'ruined the game'. If anything, over-reaction will kill the game. Getting on with it would be a good start and not requesting to be removed.
Yvonne Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 ...which is a discussion for general at the conclusion of the game
DuD Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 It wasn't baseless.. it was based on info I got on Mr-paul when I targeted you.
Sheikah Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 ...which is a discussion for general at the conclusion of the game I don't see what is left to discuss. It is what it is, people should just get on with it and stop saying the game is ruined. What I did in the grand scheme of things won't swing who wins.
Yvonne Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 a discussion is a back and forth of comments on a subject that two or more people don't completely agree on...
EEVILMURRAY Posted January 5, 2013 Posted January 5, 2013 This is fucking stupid... @EEVILMURRAY I have two questions for you: - Has your killed any other characters during this game? Has I? No. - Who have your targets been during this game's night phases? Rummy, Yvonne* and myself. *I have reread my PM and have discovered I have misread it. Yvonne did not target me night 4 ¬_¬
Nintendohnut Posted January 6, 2013 Posted January 6, 2013 This is fucking stupid... Has I? No. Rummy, Yvonne* and myself. *I have reread my PM and have discovered I have misread it. Yvonne did not target me night 4 ¬_¬ Urgh, I meant to say 'has your character killed another character in this game' but failed to type the word. That was awesome. Nobody really contributed to that list I tried to make the other day with powers etc. As I said, I doubt it will matter now, but it might be worth doing anyway.
Diageo Posted January 6, 2013 Posted January 6, 2013 It wasn't baseless.. it was based on info I got on Mr-paul when I targeted you. And what information is that?
DuD Posted January 6, 2013 Posted January 6, 2013 Just incase you missed it, because I may have been too subtle, this info... The something Sheikah has said that has really bothered me today.. not gonna point it out, but it was stupid for someone town to do. I wanna get to the bottom of this MadDog thing, so I'm not letting it brush aside, but.. I targetted Diageo last night, but recieved info on Mr-Paul. so there is a redirector hiding about? OR more likely it was due to Diageo targeting him? either way I don't believe we will hear anything from mr-p today If I've interpretted my info right. Diageo is this to do with you? who else targeted Mr-paul last night? Sheikah, you have everything on me, and I think dohnut is definitely worth protecting. I'm not questioning Mr -paul, for what is worth I believe he is town too.what I'm saying is either I was redirected (which I doubt) or I got my info due to diageo targetting mr-paul. I think Mr-paul has been silenced and I think it might have been Diageo? If its not to do with diageo, then why would I receive info about Mr-paul losing his voice when I targetted Diageo?Doesn't make sense to me? @Diageo. Maybe it'll be clearer for me if more people actually posted. I posted my suspicions of diageo last day phase when Mr-paul was silenced , but a lot of people disagreed. I'll stick by my convictions then.. Vote: Diageo The votes haven't stacked up on Rummy through what diageo has said.. I personally think diageo has the choice between roleblocker and silencer and is part of the mafia.The votes have stacked up as he's asked to be removed. Cube I've already explained my power.. yes I can end up roleblocking, but I am not a roleblocker. This info is already in the thread so I won't be going over it again.
EEVILMURRAY Posted January 6, 2013 Posted January 6, 2013 Urgh, I meant to say 'has your character killed another character in this game' but failed to type the word. That was awesome. Just so there's no illusions about this. The answer to that question is no also.
Recommended Posts