heroicjanitor Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Wow... Why havn't the mafia hit in the last couple of days? Thought Zell would be gone by now. *crazy conspiracy* if Zell were in a mafia they wouldnt have to kill as he has pointed out enough of hte other mafia to gain trust. We cant even be sure if both mafia are around anymore. The reason the mafia haven't killed in the last few days is we have a full list of colours. If they kill they will be lynched, so they have to hope we lynch each other instead. Quick question though has double vote ever been a townie power?
Zell Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 I found out Marcamillian is good. People that (in my opinion) are definately 100% good: Eenuh heroicjanitor Jonnas MadDog Marcamillian Rummy Me
Rummy Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 I'm good and was confirmed as such by as Zell, who I assume is an investigator. Do we only have one? Or anyone else who could possibly verify who/what I am? I'm good, with a double vote, I can't do anything. Marcamillian, you claimed to have NO power, right? That's something I've not seen in a mafia before. The reason the mafia haven't killed in the last few days is we have a full list of colours. If they kill they will be lynched, so they have to hope we lynch each other instead. Quick question though has double vote ever been a townie power? Yes! This has already been addressed in this thread as well iirc. In my first mafia, the Pokemafia, I had a double vote and I was town. The only time I had it when I was evil was an obvious choice double vote. Being pretty useless with my power, there's little I can do to convince you guys I'm good, so I have to hope someone else can verify Zell's info for me.
heroicjanitor Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Ok that's good to know. Someone said it was a mafia boss power to have a double vote and appar good from investigations somewhere. I wasn't aware any mafia member could kill either. Thought they had to be given the power... I found out Marcamillian is good. People that (in my opinion) are definately 100% good: Eenuh heroicjanitor Jonnas MadDog Marcamillian Rummy Me Well chairdriver is good so that leaves Nintendohnut, Sméagol, and The Peeps.
The Peeps Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Well I'm good, I only had a one-use power and I used it on Sméagol. I know all of his targets from nights 1-4. The only conclusion I could draw from it is that he didn't kill dyson on night 3, despite the write-up saying he did.. and from that I assume he's good really. What is your power by the way sméagol, I don't think you've said yet?
Jonnas Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Updated list: chairdriver Eenuh heroicjanitor Jonnas Marcamillian Rummy Zell MadDog Sméagol The Peeps Nintendohnut So, MadDog outed Tellyn, but it proves nothing. Sméagol and Peeps seem good to me, and only Nintendohnut remains. I would go with either MadDog or Nintendohnut. Which do you prefer?
Zell Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 There's also the possibility that one person has the power of appearing good when investigated.
Jonnas Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 There's also the possibility that one person has the power of appearing good when investigated. Which excludes Rummy and Marcamillian. But still, who should we go after?
The Peeps Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Why does it exclude those two? Who are we most suspicious of at the moment? I'd still like to know Sméagol's power because I think maybe I dismissed him as townie too easily.
Jonnas Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Why does it exclude those two? From my suspect list, I mean. The others that Zell confirmed as good are ones that naturally strike me as good. New post: D'oh! My blue list, it's what I meant. It excludes them from that one.
MadDog Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 I'm good. I voted for every mafioso to go down. My power would be pointless if I wasn't good. How do we know there's 2 mafias btw? I must of missed that.
The Peeps Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Well from the very first write-up where two shots are fired and from 2 people dying each night for the first few nights.
heroicjanitor Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 How do we know there's 2 mafias btw? I must of missed that. Mundi killed MoogleViper on the first night even though both were mafia. Dyson and Tellyn both tried to get each other killed.
Marcamillian Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Updated list: chairdriver Eenuh heroicjanitor Jonnas Marcamillian Rummy Zell MadDog Sméagol The Peeps Nintendohnut Wouldn't this list give Town the majority? 7 not to mention the doublevote?
chairdriver Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 Wouldn't this list give Town the majority? 7 not to mention the doublevote? What are you on about? Town always has the majority. If it doesn't, it's lost.
Sméagol Posted October 4, 2010 Posted October 4, 2010 To be honest, it's most effective when I don't say anything about it, so I won't reveal anything unless I have to. But Zell can target me tonight, no problem.
Nintendohnut Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Well my power is basically completely useless at this point, so I might as well just reveal it as I'm not a target and I can't help the town. I am Magenta as you know, and my power is to target a player and receive any PMs that player may get from Dannyboy. I'll just check through my PMs to see who I have targeted so far. Night 1: Targeted Diageo, got nothing Night 2: Targeted Cube. Got information that he had received about Diageo, one half of the Black/white pair. Didn't see the point in revealing this as it would make me a target. Night 3: Targeted The Peeps, got nothing Night 4: Didn't do anything this night I think? I forget to send a PM either night 4 or 5, but either way it's not important because... Night 5: Targeted jayseven, got nothing Night 6: Targeted Eenuh (thought she had roleclaimed investigator so I might get something useful. I was wrong.) got nothing. So yeah, as you can see me role is annoying. The most annoying thing is that now that everyone knows who everyone else is, the only use I have is if I target someone who is silenced or killed at night, so that I can still reveal their info. But as a) The mafia apparently has no silencer and b) they aren't killing anyone, it's pointless. If anyone thinks it would be a good idea for me to target them from now on then let me know, but as I say, I am totally pointless. I'm sort of just riding this game through now, trying to vote when I can. I don't have a lot of time to spend on these games at the moment sadly, and most people know how much I will usually put into them. So yeah, I'm not a evil, I'd say investigate me but people seem to think the final mafia member will appear good anyway so that won't help. If anyone has any questions fire away, I've tried to be as honest as I can. As I say, my power is pretty useless as a great deal of people either do nothing or don't receive a PM.
Eenuh Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Well my power is basically completely useless at this point, so I might as well just reveal it as I'm not a target and I can't help the town. I am Magenta as you know, and my power is to target a player and receive any PMs that player may get from Dannyboy. I'll just check through my PMs to see who I have targeted so far. Night 1: Targeted Diageo, got nothing Night 2: Targeted Cube. Got information that he had received about Diageo, one half of the Black/white pair. Didn't see the point in revealing this as it would make me a target. Night 3: Targeted The Peeps, got nothing Night 4: Didn't do anything this night I think? I forget to send a PM either night 4 or 5, but either way it's not important because... Night 5: Targeted jayseven, got nothing Night 6: Targeted Eenuh (thought she had roleclaimed investigator so I might get something useful. I was wrong.) got nothing. So yeah, as you can see me role is annoying. The most annoying thing is that now that everyone knows who everyone else is, the only use I have is if I target someone who is silenced or killed at night, so that I can still reveal their info. But as a) The mafia apparently has no silencer and b) they aren't killing anyone, it's pointless. If anyone thinks it would be a good idea for me to target them from now on then let me know, but as I say, I am totally pointless. I'm sort of just riding this game through now, trying to vote when I can. I don't have a lot of time to spend on these games at the moment sadly, and most people know how much I will usually put into them. So yeah, I'm not a evil, I'd say investigate me but people seem to think the final mafia member will appear good anyway so that won't help. If anyone has any questions fire away, I've tried to be as honest as I can. As I say, my power is pretty useless as a great deal of people either do nothing or don't receive a PM. Heh I never said I was an investigator. =P I underline people's names. That's all I do. And since we know everyone's colour, my power is pretty useless now too.
The Peeps Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Didn't you say you get a bit of information on players too though, Eenuh? I'm sure you did...
Eenuh Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Didn't you say you get a bit of information on players too though, Eenuh? I'm sure you did... By that I meant I get to know what colour a person is. Since you know, they get underlined. That's the only thing I do.
chairdriver Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 By that I meant I get to know what colour a person is. Since you know, they get underlined. That's the only thing I do. No, since colour is completely variable in the write-ups, you get to see what a player did, not what colour they are.
Eenuh Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Hmm true. Keep forgetting about people changing colours. =(
The Peeps Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Well I'm good, I only had a one-use power and I used it on Sméagol. I know all of his targets from nights 1-4. The only conclusion I could draw from it is that he didn't kill dyson on night 3, despite the write-up saying he did.. and from that I assume he's good really. What is your power by the way sméagol, I don't think you've said yet? It's like 6 posts up, chair ;P I am dark red. I could target one person and see their targets for each night up to and including the night I use it. It was a one-time use power. I used it on Sméagol and can divulge his targets if you really want but I don't know what good it would do as you can already find out his targets now we know everyone's colour. On the night that Dyson was apparently killed by blue (as well as others), Sméagol had actually targeted zell. It also said he failed that night (obviously).
Sméagol Posted October 5, 2010 Posted October 5, 2010 Well my power is basically completely useless at this point, so I might as well just reveal it as I'm not a target and I can't help the town. I am Magenta as you know, and my power is to target a player and receive any PMs that player may get from Dannyboy. I'll just check through my PMs to see who I have targeted so far. [..] Actually, you can target me as well. As long as you don't reveal anything unnecessary..(?). ########## (In case I die)
Recommended Posts