Super Mario 3D World
It looks really nice, but it just feels dated. I just had no desire to play beyond world 3 (can't remember where i stopped).
Destiny (not really critically acclaimed)
I was sucked into the hype after the alpha and beta. It's the most soulless game i've ever played. Technically, it's very good, but not for me.
Mass Effect
Tried to get into it 3 times but i just stop after a few hours. Tried it on PS3 and PC and i just hate it.