Dyson Posted July 7, 2011 Author Posted July 7, 2011 Votes Rummy (3) - Brian Mcoy, Ellmeister, Tales Majority is 4
Brian Mcoy Posted July 7, 2011 Posted July 7, 2011 Mcoy thinks that pretty much narrows down who our double voter is.
Rummy Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 Yes I have a double vote as former mayor, but I haven't lied about anything. I was going to come clean with it but thought better with it being late days. I also pointed out I've been reluctant to vote all game because of it. Err...bullshit. Go back and show me where I've said I have no power, and also explain how your reasoning applies more to me than to McCoy who has come out saying he has absolutely no power at all when I haven't. I also noticed how you and a few others leaped to his defense saying it's cool for him to have no power, but none of you did that for me. Definitely raises doubts in my mind. Can't believe the sort of bullshit votes you guys jump on. I planned a whole reveal after this post, but amazingly nobody even seemed to take notice/pushed it, so I didn't feel a need to. Double votes are crucial at the end, thought if people wanted to assume despite this rather obvious post that I had no power, I was happy to sit with that. I have to say, Rummy has been a suspect for me for a while. If only I'd tracked him like I had intended to STUPID PAUL.However, Mcoy isn't out of my targets after he seemingly was distracting us from Eddie in the last day phase. Need to give Rummy a chance to speak, and I think I'll have a total read through later tonight. I didn't kill last night because I can't, he was on his way to me and got interrupted by someone else.
Tales Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 A former mayor? And with a double vote like the current (dead) mayor? Makes sense they would be opposites. Finish him.
Rummy Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 Why does it make sense? Why is it still of no concern to people that Mcoy has apparently no power?
Mr-Paul Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 Eddie had no power apart from to kill as well. It said the power was then passed on. To me, both of you could be mafia. Did another townie have a double vote then? If so, I'm not sure whether to believe either of Mcoy and Rummy.
Diageo Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 If Rummy got EddieColeslaw's killing power, then he would lose his double vote wouldn't he? So if he still has a double vote, then he can't be the killer. That's my theory. I was certain that if Eddie was mafia then so is McCoy, and I'm still pretty sure. If it's between Rummy and McCoy, I think it's McCoy. Vote: McCoy
Dyson Posted July 8, 2011 Author Posted July 8, 2011 Votes Rummy (3) - Brian Mcoy, Ellmeister, Tales Brian Mcoy (1) - Diageo Majority is 4
Brian Mcoy Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 If Rummy got EddieColeslaw's killing power, then he would lose his double vote wouldn't he? So if he still has a double vote, then he can't be the killer. That's my theory. I was certain that if Eddie was mafia then so is McCoy, and I'm still pretty sure. If it's between Rummy and McCoy, I think it's McCoy. Vote: McCoy Or Mcoy was right with his earlier posts that you are a member of the mafia and are working with Rummy. Mcoy stated his role right from the start and everyone who has investigated, reverse tracked or role blocked Mcoy came up with nothing other then Mcoy is a person with no power. Mcoy believe you even stated that he was telling 90% of the truth (If that's even your role) If Mcoy was lying then he'd probably consider that percentage to be quite a long way off. The facts are there is a double voter, the towns mayor is dead and it's fair to say that the mafia also has a double voter who we've clearly narrowed down to Rummy.
Diageo Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 I was investigated, just as you were. So if you're good, I also have to be good. I still don't think that Rummy was the killer, because no one seems to have more than one power, and if Rummy could kill and have a double vote, then it wouldn't go with the theme. So if he still has his double vote now, then he can't be the killer. I think you are the killer. And even if Rummy is mafia. I think you are too. If after we get rid of you, the game hasn't ended, then I would go for Rummy.
Brian Mcoy Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 If Mcoy and Rummy were both mafia why would Mcoy have bothered to point out right at the start of this day about the double vote power. Mcoy doubts giving away him and his partner would be a very good game plan. Mcoy and yourself are clearly at a disagreement here. Mcoy may have looked sucpicious to not vote Eddie yesterday but Mcoy would also like to point out that Jayseven investigated Mcoy last night and found Mcoy to have no power, Mcoy has clearly not gained any powers. Mcoy would also like to point out that Rummy did not vote for Eddier either.
Diageo Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 Jaysevem only finds your job or clues about you. Not if you have a power or not. But it does make me a little hesitant. I had forgotten about jayseven's investigation. It's just weird that no one has every investigated or targeted Rummy ever.
jayseven Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 Well so far I've at least gained clues to what roles people have - diageo, remember, you're a psychiatrist and i found WEIRD MASKS and A WATCH and you're all "..." about that. But yeah, found nothing with mcoy.
Diageo Posted July 8, 2011 Posted July 8, 2011 Agh, this is annoying. I have a really strong feeling McCoy is mafia but there isn't really anything backing it up besides his behaviour. But with Rummy he has a double vote, but I think my theory is true that he's not the killer.
Rummy Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 That would be a good theory, because I'm definitely not the killer. If Mcoy and Rummy were both mafia why would Mcoy have bothered to point out right at the start of this day about the double vote power. Mcoy doubts giving away him and his partner would be a very good game plan. Mcoy and yourself are clearly at a disagreement here. Mcoy may have looked sucpicious to not vote Eddie yesterday but Mcoy would also like to point out that Jayseven investigated Mcoy last night and found Mcoy to have no power, Mcoy has clearly not gained any powers. Mcoy would also like to point out that Rummy did not vote for Eddier either. That's because, as I've been saying all game, I find it strange that you actually have no power at all. I knew I had one, just not an active one, I still don't think you'd have no power at all! I suspected both you and Eddie and tbh you're the only other viable suspicion I have, Vote:Mcoy. I was sure Cube cleared me somewhere, and as I've said I haven't actually lied about anything in the thread.
Dyson Posted July 9, 2011 Author Posted July 9, 2011 Votes Rummy (3): Brian Mcoy, Ellmeister, Tales Brian Mcoy (3): Diageo, Rummy Majority is 4
Mr-Paul Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 Having a full thread read through, then will make my decision. Bare with me for an hour.
Dyson Posted July 9, 2011 Author Posted July 9, 2011 Bare with me for an hour. i c wut u did ther lol
Mr-Paul Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 Lol. After a read through, still dodgy about both and unsure that there would be two town double voters. However, Jonnas was a townie with no role and was highlighted as special. Mcoy comes across as slightly more suspicious, and Eddie was just a mafioso with no power but to kill and it was passed on. So Vote: Mcoy. If he's town, let's keep an eye on Rummy tonight.
Brian Mcoy Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 Lol. After a read through, still dodgy about both and unsure that there would be two town double voters. However, Jonnas was a townie with no role and was highlighted as special. Mcoy comes across as slightly more suspicious, and Eddie was just a mafioso with no power but to kill and it was passed on. So Vote: Mcoy. If he's town, let's keep an eye on Rummy tonight. Mcoy would like to point out there won't be a tomorrow as the mafia will now kill one of you and have the majority : / Mcoy cannot honestly believe you're lynching him for being sucpicious when we have Rummy with HARD evidence that he's mafia with double vote powers. Mcoy will try and get Dyson's attention so the day phase can end, It's been fun ^^
Tales Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 I think mr-paul is a mafia who waited in the bushes until there were 3 votes on Mcoy. I don't believe we would have not just two townie double voters, but two mayors. Story wise it makes sense for them to be on opposite teams and that should be enough for a lynch.
Mr-Paul Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 Believe me, I'm not mafia. If I were I would have gunned for Mcoy long ago. I had to go through the thread totally before finally leaning that way. Read through earlier in the thread. I was insistent Rummy was evil. He still could be. But Mcoys defence of Eddie, the fact that when Jonnas was good, died and had no power it was highlighted as special, and the fact that Eddie was just a mafia who could kill and the power was passed on, makes me think that Mcoy is mafia. If the game doesn't end now, I will be tracking what Rummy is up to, and you will need to make a very good guess on who will be targeted to be killed Tales, so hopefully your reverse track power can actually be useful for the first time in the game.
Tales Posted July 9, 2011 Posted July 9, 2011 Haha, remember Pokemafia? I ended up as one of the final five and not once did I reverse track the victim. I barely reverse tracked anyone who was targeted. In this game I haven't got anything >_>
Recommended Posts