Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 My reasons are: Nintendohnut is mafia, better for the town. Nintendohnut is town, I'm surely a more capable cop than he, there wouldn't be no capable cops. Either way, I think those reasons are good. If people believe I'm town, you would rather have a bad cop than a good one?
heroicjanitor Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 At the end of this day a townie will be dead. Right now we have two options: 1. We can try and take a mafia while we're at it(Eddie could be mafia, but it's still a risk) 2. Or we can make sure the better investigator of the two survives.
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 My sidekick also doesn't silence, which is better too. What possible use could we have for that?
Mr-Paul Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 But what about the other two? I think dohnut has a better explanation/alibi than the others tbh. Yet we've focussed solely on him because of you, Diageo. Is your sidekick Pooh then?
heroicjanitor Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I'm leaning towards keeping the better investigator because it would be unfair to just lynch Eddie within a 3 minute spell and he mightn't even be mafia.
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I was away most of the day, they weren't here either, and they probably won't come on before the day is over. They are stalling it out. You want the day to end with no lynch, wasted? My sidekick is Winnie the Pooh, yes.
Nintendohnut Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I was away most of the day, they weren't here either, and they probably won't come on before the day is over. They are stalling it out. You want the day to end with no lynch, wasted? YOU HAVE WASTED THIS DAY. SERIOUSLY, READ THE POSTS. I'm just as useful as an investigator now that I know I'm a dumb cop, as my results will just be reversed. I would also like to clarify that I got a PM saying Eddie was maifa, just as I did with Diageo, who was good. Therefore I will LYNCH: Dannyboy as I suspect he may actually be the killer. What does Pooh ... do?
Beast Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Wait, I'm confused. Dohnut, are you saying that whatever you say, it's reversed?
Mr-Paul Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 We don't know when the day will end. It depends on whenever chairdriver gets on/decides it'll end. Personally, I would actually prefer a no lynch to either of you being killed. it's a too big risk. If I really wanted to be selfish I could put a vote on to lynch Nintendohnut so I could use my sidekick at night, but i'm not going to. I feel it will be more useful if we find more out about him tonight.
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Have either of them been online? How can we question them without them being online? It's not wasting the day if I believe you are mafia. Also, it's not so clear, you have as much evidence that you are a dumb cop than that you are paranoid or anything else. It's too big a risk? What's the risk?
Beast Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I'm not voting at all, I'm way too confused. Sorry. Change vote: Nobody
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Also, you can't have a no lynch over any of us being killed, because I will die with no lynch.
Nintendohnut Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Wait, I'm confused. Dohnut, are you saying that whatever you say, it's reversed? Sorry I may not have been clear. A dumb cop receives information that is opposite to the truth. So I got 'Diageo is mafia' and 'Eddicolslaw is mafia' which means they are/were both townies. When I get a message saying 'xxxxxx is a townie' then that means they're evil.
heroicjanitor Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Nintendohnut you could just receive that they are mafia regardless. No proof that you receive the opposite. OR it could be randomised.
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 What if you're a paranoid cop Nintendohnut, assuming you're not just lying. How do you know if either Eddie or Dannyboy is mafia. We're just shooting blindly here. Exactly Nintendohnut, you have no proof you are a dumb cop over randomisation or paranoia.
Ellmeister Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I've just spent more time catching up with this and nothing useful has come of it except the same old squabbles and reasoning being used since this afternoon. It has become stale. Diageo is either proven to be lying about his need to lynch someone or he is dead unfortunately anyway once Chair finishes the day. I have no idea what my sidekick does.
Nintendohnut Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Well if I was anything but a dumb cop now I would be entirely useless, and that's not the sort of role chairdriver would put in a game like this. A vanilla mafia, perhaps, but this is too complex to have a townie just sitting doing nothing. Your sidekick's role should be mentioned in your original PM Diageo, what does Pooh Bear do?
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 We already have a proper cop right here. And with all the deals going on, and resurrections and extra powers, you would hardly just be standing there.
Ellmeister Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I've read my sidekick's role and its not exactly clear, though I think I may have an idea of what they are supposed to do.
Jonnas Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Ok STOP IT! Both of you! Behave! The day has ended, so Diageo dies. I would've liked to see Nintendohnut lynched, so we would have a mafia dead, or a confirmed townie in Diageo, but no cigar. Now, after I thought things through, I do believe either Eddie or Dannyboy are to be followed, like Dohnut said. There is also the possibility that Dohnut is actually the mafioso who killed, and he swayed us with his highly persuasive speeches. But that's a distant possibility.
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Will you stop automerging that in, I keep not seeing it. Winnie tells me how effective my investigators are, since I send one of my friends to do the investigating. So it could possibly tell me if they were redirected or misinformed.
Mr-Paul Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 I both love and hate how paranoid/confusing this game is.
heroicjanitor Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Diageo really does sound like a better investigator. You should have mentioned what Winnie does sooner. Nintendohnut could be virtually useless.
Diageo Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Jonnas like Mr Paul says, the nights and days run longer if Chairdriver is busy.
Jonnas Posted December 4, 2010 Posted December 4, 2010 Jonnas like Mr Paul says, the nights and days run longer if Chairdriver is busy. ...Well, my vote is still against Nintendohnut. At least we can get a more reliable investigator out of this ordeal.
Recommended Posts