Cube Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Oh, and sorry for revealing my info in tiny bits - I was making a trap and hoping for Zell to claim he protected MadDog.
jayseven Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Actually I didn't target myself last night. Normally Jonnas PMs me with the number of people I fend off but I guess nobody targetted Cube as I did. I will say, though, that it's at least the second time I've been switched with maddog. That's peep's role, is it not? Mind elaborating on why you'd do this? Was trying to decypher something from the voting patterns, but it's really hard to keep note of it without, well, without notes. And I wish you'd stop suspecting me, it's a complete waste of time.
ReZourceman Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Eenuh/other investigators' what'd you find out last night?
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 It's probably safe to assume that based on the line about Diageo suspecting the killer all along, we could deduce who the next mafia scumnag is by looking at Diageo's suspects.
jayseven Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Fairly sure diageo's suspected just about everyone. The write-up suggests that perhaps it was his target that killed him, or that it was someone he/we trusted all along. Which is a horrible revelation, if true.
The Peeps Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 It's the first time you've been switched with MadDog, at least by me. I thought MadDog would be a target for the mafia (and he was) and you had said that you were going to be protecting yourself. So I thought a good way to protect MadDog would be to make anyone targeting him target you instead - and hopefully you'd be protected by yourself. It's one of the only actual useful things I could've done with my power. Unless by some luck I manage to re-target the killer to target a fellow mafioso, my power doesn't really help all that much. Now that Zell has been found to be mafia I don't think there's much reason to suspect Jayseven. We've got one straight protector, one jailkeeper and one investigator/protector. Probably all townie.
ReZourceman Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 I had considered the same Danny. I had pondered that the tripping over could be one of your traps, but then he never really distrusted you. Nintendohnut is probably near the top of that list. The Usual Suspects Cube - Investigator/protector (say wha) Dannyboy-the-Dane - Killer/needs to find princess Eenuh - Investigator heroicjanitor - Day ....was it lie detector or am I getting confused? Jayseven - Reverse roleblock/quasi uber protector MadDog - Double vote / investigator Marcamillian - Roleblock/jailkeep Nintendohnut - Uses plants ReZourceman - "Follow" redirector Rummy - Reverse tracker The Peeps - Redirector
The Peeps Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 If you count The Butler, it seems the town have an awful lot of investigators...
Marcamillian Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 MAIFA TREMBLE BEFORE ME! I AM THE ALMIGHTY PROCASINATOR. FEAR MY ALMIGHTY VOTE LIST!(format is voter - votee - reason... page numbers for reference based on standard 25 posts per page) VOTE LIST DAY 2 pg 2 The Peeps - Smeagol HeroJan - Smeagol chair - Smeagol (diageo refuses Smeagol) Danny: Smeagol Maddog - Smeagol Aqui1a - Smeagol pg 3 Paj - Smeagol Tales - Smeagol Dyson - Smeagol danny - withdraw heroicJan - withdraw - only voting for info pg 4 Chair - Diageo ReZ - Diageo Aqui1a - Diageo Cube - Smeagol Danny - Smeagol ReZ- withdraw Chair - Smeagol HeroicJan - Smeagol Paj - Smeagol Dohnut - Smeagol VOTE LIST DAY 3 pg 6 HeroicJan - Diageo ReZ - Diageo pg 7 Ell - Aqui1a heroicJan - withdraw pg 8 Tales - Diageo VOTE LIST DAY 4 pg9 Ell - Diageo pg10 Maddog - Diageo Cube - Maddog ReZ - Maddog HeroicJan - Maddog Diageo - Maddog pg 12 ReZ - Dohnut Diageo - withdraw Eenuh - Dohnut HeroicJan - Dohnut Diageo - Dohnut pg13 cube - Dohnut Maddog - Dohnut Peeps - Dohnut Diageo - Withdraw pg14 Diageo - dlt pg 15 Peeps - ReZ pg 16 ReZ - withdraw maddog - withdraw HeroicJan - chairdriver Tales - dohnut Diageo - ReZ pg 17 Maddog - Rez danny - ReZ Cube - ReZ ReZ - Chair Dohnut - ReZ pg18 heroic - withdraw heroicJan - ReZ Peeps - withdraw Peeps - ReZ gmac - ReZ VOTE LIST DAY 5 Pg 20 MadDog - Cube - "duke" Pg 21 Jay - MadDog - cant remember, jump on cube, tentative Pg 22 Cube - Ell - Bribary The Peeps - gmac - inactivity Cube - gmac Ell - Diageo - cant target pg 23 Diageo - Gmac - inactivity heroicjanitor - gmac pg 24 nintendohnut - diageo danny - Diageo - suspicious danny - withdraw pg 26 Rummy - Diageo Maddog - Diageo pg 29 Maddog - ReZ - Name stall jay - ReZ - lolz Tales - Diageo Peeps - withdraw pg 31 Zell - Diageo - fishy mr-paul - Jay - roleblock description pg 32 heroicJan - jay the peeps - jay - dont knwo much Diageo - jay - give information pg 33 Zell - jay - pressure Peeps - RUmmy - bad logic pg 34 Jay - Diageo - padding thread Diageo - removed HeroicJan - removed mr-paul - remove vote Diageo - Rummy - R suspects him, hero, peeps, Rez pg 35 heroicJan- Gmac Ell - gmac - following crowd Diageo - gmac - "willing to" ?? ReZ - gmac - not in propper format "I am also willing to " pg 36 Eenuh - gmac - no contribution Rummy - gmac - pains him to VOTE LIST DAY 6 pg 37 ReZ - Marcamillian ThePeeps - Marcamillian ThePeeps - remove vote - just got role pg 38 ReZ - Remove Vote - Not had time to post ThePeeps - Rummy - not adressing fencing Diageo - Gmac - resume last day pg 39 Diageo - Rummy - disproves people pg 40 Maddog - Gmac - dont like the sound of Cube - Gmac - willing to Tales - gmac - sounds good ThePeeps - Gmac Diageo - gmac - he's homo Marcamillian - gmac - not princess pg 41 Cube - remove vote - discussion pg 43 ReZ - gmac Cube - Gmac - found out everything we can today (majority reached) ThePeeps - RemoveVote - CubeReZ relationship pg 44 ThePeeps - Gmac - day ending mr-paul - gmac - majority (the peeps had said one till majority - forgot about double vote) VOTE LIST DAY 7 pg 45 Maddog - Zell - map stealing HeriocJ - Zell - map & existing suspicions Cube - Zell pg 46 ThePeeps - Zell - info/inactive/convenient map Jay - Zell HeriocJ - RemoveVote ThePeeps - RemoveVote Maddog - Tales Cube - Tales ReZ - Tales Diageo - RemoveVote Jay... if you want to look at voting patterns this should help. Also, considering the confusion last day phase... why didn't you come forward about not targetting yourself yesterday?
ReZourceman Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 If you count The Butler, it seems the town have an awful lot of investigators... Indeed. Indeed, indeed. This is just worrying. Honestly. The only person who I think any of us can absolutely believe to be 100% townie is MadDog, as he has been so instrumental in (1, or a few) mafia lynchings. Sickeningly well played game, interesting game and good game, chaps.
Marcamillian Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 ---------------- Sorry.. you meant LAST night
MadDog Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 It has been an awesome game so far. Would be even better if the town won. I targeted Marcamillian last night, i found that he is great in and out of a fight, and after a couple of hits, he got me out of his room. I don't know what to think of it, really.
Dannyboy-the-Dane Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 I had considered the same Danny. I had pondered that the tripping over could be one of your traps, but then he never really distrusted you. I think the limping, along with the music, was just a reference to House M.D., another doctor. He also limps, doesn't he?
jayseven Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 I said that I was going to protect myself yesterday in the hope that the mafia would refrain from targetting me, thus allowing me to target someone else for safety. I didn't take into account peep's ability... If we have that many investigators then I think it'd be handy if they all came out with their list of targets and info -- yes I know I'm a broken record, but it makes sense. marc - I'd love to, but we're currently at 37 pages at 40 posts per page. I went through the thread when we were at 30, and it took me 3-4 hours. I can have a look over just the day/night write-ups in a couple, probably. I had a brisk look just now and was specifically looking at the late voters for the certified evil. It's no mean feat.
ReZourceman Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Dannyboy....how does your power work? In terms of how its worded.....like....do you choose just to target people and IF that player is the princess then it doesn't kill them?
Marcamillian Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 ... the quote posted is a list of peoples votes.. it was intended as an aid so you didnt have to look through them.
Diageo Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 The fact there was House music, implying that I was House with the text, I loved it. Don't care I'm dead now.
Eenuh Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Jay: here's the voting patterns I kept track of. voted for Smeagol (evil): The Peeps, MadDog, Tales, Dyson, Cube, Dannyboy-the-Dane, chairdriver, heroicjanitor, Paj Meen Ah/Marcamillian voted for gmac (evil): MadDog, Tales, The Peeps, Diageo, Marcamillian, Rummy, ReZ, Cube voted for Tales (good): MadDog, Cube, ReZourceman, Diageo, jayseven, Nintendohnut, Marcamillian voted for Zell (evil): Eenuh, Cube, Dannyboy-the-Dane, jayseven, The Peeps, ReZ, Diageo
jayseven Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Peeps, maddog, marc, myself - my little list of surely-come-on-now-they-must-be town. cube, ReZ, Heroicjan and Eenuh are my "hmm more likely good than bad" list. Dannyboy, nintendohnut, rummy are my Suspicious trio. ... These suspicion lists, I've just realised, help in no way whatsoever.
MadDog Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 From those voting patterns there is a few that look dodgy. I'll do abit more reading and post with more.
Eenuh Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 I've got a few suspects as well but I want to hear from other people first. Maybe someone has some sort of information to go on.
MadDog Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 From that list, i'd say ReZ looks quite bad from that list. Does anyone have anything on him? He voted late for 2 mafia, and early for one good. The mafia always put in a vote or two when voting of their own, and they obviously do it for the last 2/3 votes.
jayseven Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Looks like nintendohnut and ReZ are the most suspicious. Nintendohnut never lynched a mafia (though I do recall he previously said he didn't have much net time -- but that doesn't mean he's not mafia). ReZ was always a late lyncher (but he voted for chair early on)... Danny's posting pattern moves him down the suspicion list.
ReZourceman Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 From that list, i'd say ReZ looks quite bad from that list. Does anyone have anything on him? He voted late for 2 mafia, and early for one good. The mafia always put in a vote or two when voting of their own, and they obviously do it for the last 2/3 votes. Actually I was the third person to vote for Zell. I removed and put on in the same post as a joke. There are a few people missing entirely from a couple of the evils.
MadDog Posted November 23, 2010 Posted November 23, 2010 Actually I was the third person to vote for Zell. I removed and put on in the same post as a joke. There are a few people missing entirely from a couple of the evils. But if a mafia is close to being lynched, the mafia see that as an opportunity to move them up peoples good list. Obviously not voting at all might look bad, but voting late is also suspicious in my eyes.
Recommended Posts