The Peeps Posted February 4, 2012 Posted February 4, 2012 You were backing me up too much mr-paul Interesting that mr-paul shows up as vanilla because I thought he targeted me on night one which is the only reason why I trusted him lol. I guess it was just a good bluff. People I'm suspicious of: Jonnas and heroicjanitor. I've not investigated either of these people.
DuD Posted February 4, 2012 Posted February 4, 2012 Im suspicious of Jonnas too.. Mainly due to EEVIL making the slip up of revealing he role blocked you in an attempt to clear Jonnas? Seems silly to reveal the roleblock, to gain nothing?
Jonnas Posted February 4, 2012 Posted February 4, 2012 Well, now is that awkward moment where someone I believed to be good turned out to be mafia, instead. Eevil, I am disappoint. The bad part is, he basically outed himself...because The Peeps was asking me questions. Puts me in a tight spot. Anyway, I don't suppose The Peeps investigated me. Thankfully, I can prove I'm a vanilla townie, it's just too bad Peeps didn't see my hint.
heroicjanitor Posted February 4, 2012 Posted February 4, 2012 Well I didn't think a mafia would admit to roleblocking the town's investigator... Still doesn't make sense :/ I was expecting to spend the day questioning Jimbob when he suddenly last voted
The Peeps Posted February 4, 2012 Posted February 4, 2012 Because I'm totes mafia. I checked out someone else on an itch... I have a horrible feeling that jonnas would be a wasted investigation. Jimbob was another suspicion of mine but I don't think he's mafia.
Nintendohnut Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 Peps, you really might as well reveal who you have investigated so far. If you were to die tonight,e for example, we'd have a list of people that you've found to be good that we can cross off the suspect list. Seeing as the mafia already know who they all are and are simply trying to pick off people at random, they gain nothing from you revealing your investigation results (if, for example, you said 'xxx, xxx and xxx are all good' it wouldn't be new information for the mafia, as they already know that every one is a target. However, for us, we now know that we don't have to question those people. It will also give any protectors around an idea of who else they can target without helping out a mafioso accidentally. I don't know why I've posted this, but I seem to remember yesterday it being a point of discussion that I didn't have time to express my opinion on. So yeah. Vote patterns would be useful here, I'll have a quick look back over who voted for who in the last few days. ReZourceman (EVIL) (8): The Peeps, Eenuh, Jonnas, Cube, Diageo, heroicjanitor, ReZourceman, Jimbob Rummy (GOOD) (8): EEVILMURRAY, Diageo, heroicjanitor, Jonnas, DuD, Jimbob, Cube, Shorty EEVILMURRAY (EVIL) (7): The Peeps, mr-paul, Diageo, Nintendohnut, Cube, DuD, Jimbob So from this I can see the following things - heroic voted just before Rez in the first lynch. Rez had given up at this point and was just trying to end the day. Heroic also voted for Rummy, but not for EEVILMURRAY. - Jimbob has voted late in all the votes but was earlier in the townie vote. For the other two he's been the last voter. - Shorty is the only player who voted for the townie lynch but not either of the mafia lynches - Diageo likes voting :p - Out of the remaining players, jayseven is the only one who hasn't voted for any of the lynches. Don't know what this all tells us but thought it would be useful to look at. I could also include the first day in which people voted a lot for me and for Rummy, but as the votes switched around so much it's difficult to tell who's voting for who and when.
Diageo Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 I think I'm going to go with my gut on this one. Vote: Jonnas
heroicjanitor Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 ReZourceman (EVIL) (8): The Peeps, Eenuh, Jonnas, Cube, Diageo, heroicjanitor, ReZourceman, Jimbob Rummy (GOOD) (8): EEVILMURRAY, Diageo, heroicjanitor, Jonnas, DuD, Jimbob, Cube, Shorty EEVILMURRAY (EVIL) (7): The Peeps, mr-paul, Diageo, Nintendohnut, Cube, DuD, Jimbob So from this I can see the following things - heroic voted just before Rez in the first lynch. Rez had given up at this point and was just trying to end the day. Heroic also voted for Rummy, but not for EEVILMURRAY. - Jimbob has voted late in all the votes but was earlier in the townie vote. For the other two he's been the last voter. - Shorty is the only player who voted for the townie lynch but not either of the mafia lynches - Diageo likes voting :p - Out of the remaining players, jayseven is the only one who hasn't voted for any of the lynches. Don't know what this all tells us but thought it would be useful to look at. I could also include the first day in which people voted a lot for me and for Rummy, but as the votes switched around so much it's difficult to tell who's voting for who and when. Good research but I don't think I'd have co-ordinated that if I was mafia :p Diageo does like voting it seems, Jonnas said he can prove himself though. Unless he means a Peeps investigation.
The Peeps Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 I'm reluctant to give out my info while there is still a protector. I know it's selfish but if I'm getting protection eac& night, I can win this game for the town. At the moment, the mafia can't instigate any votes with any confidence. If anyone starts voting for townie I knew about, I will stop it. A list wouldn't do the town good, we wouldn't suddenly have any leads. The mafia can only pick people off at random at the moment and that is good for the town. I will be stubborn on this. I have 2 people in mind for investigation but I'm open to suggestions.
Diageo Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 You were basically certain that Jonnas was mafia yesterday, The Peeps. Why the change of heart?
The Peeps Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 No change of heart, he's still pretty dodge. I was just thinking about the likelihood of both him and EEVIL being mafia... would be a bit silly for 2 members of the mafia to come after me like that although as I said before, it could have just been a risky play from them. I'm intrigued as to what your hint was though Jonnas as I've obviously completely missed it.
Diageo Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 I'm pretty sure that Eevil attempted to get attention off Jonnas with his little stunt because he made the mistake of thinking you had claimed to target Jonnas. Anyway, we have a good few players that are being very quiet. How about a little opinion piece on who each person thinks is suspicious? @%1; @Shorty @Cube @heroicjanitor @DuD @Jimbob @uəʌəsʎɐɾ .
The Peeps Posted February 5, 2012 Posted February 5, 2012 Of those, I find heroicjanitor most suspicious. I'm willing to put a vote down on Jonnas to get something done today. Vote: Jonnas
Cube Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Personally, I've found Jonnas to be suspicious for a few days, but with no particular basis on why.
Jonnas Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 For starters, we need to clear up the whole "winning condition" business. Vanilla townies such as myself cannot give a straight answer to such a request. That was my point all along. I mean seriously, check your role PMs. I found it strange that Peeps asked such a question in the first place, honestly. I do realize my entire point hinges on the fact that every vanilla townie got the same PM as me, but it's all I got. You can vote and you can talk all you want, Peeps, you're the one who hasn't thought about the implications of asking a townie about their win condition. By the way, I noticed the hint appeared in a rather large post. Not as clear as I thought it was.
Jimbob Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Well, at the moment i don't have any information to provide that could assist with who to go for. To be honest, i have no idea who to go for either. So i'm going to vote in pattern with everyone this time, just to get things moving. Vote: Jonnas Again, i'm only voting to get things moving.
Jonnas Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 NEW POST: Also, I should add this, just in case. My suspicions lie in Cube, Jayseven and Shorty (all hunches). Especially Jayseven.
The Peeps Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Remove vote just because I'm not sure. I'm being flakey tonight apparently.
DuD Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Im suspicious of Jonnas too.. Mainly due to EEVIL making the slip up of revealing he role blocked you in an attempt to clear Jonnas? Seems silly to reveal the roleblock, to gain nothing? @Diageo, how about reading the thread :p
Diageo Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 People are "suspicious" but no one is doing anything.
Jimbob Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 I'm sticking to my vote, it's the best i can do at this time
The Peeps Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Vote: Jonnas then. I guess we'll learn something from it even if he's town. I'm not sure on him but I am leaning more towards Jonnas being mafia than town. 2 or 3 mafia players left... it'll be a while before they can get majority.
DuD Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Vote: Jonnas I thought it might make sense for Peeps to check him out first, but it seems he's not going to.
Cube Posted February 6, 2012 Posted February 6, 2012 Based on what Jonnas said about his PM...I don't think he's mafia any more.
Recommended Posts