Sheikah

Why be difficult? Please read my post again - it explains how 'someone targeted X' is an impossible to detect lie. The perfect lie.

DuD already admitted to knowing esqeuiel was a roleblocker (so chances are VERY high he must have targeted esequiel) And think about it for a minute. "Some targeted Joe Bloggs" ^ How does one dispute this claim? I'll tell you how: A reverse tracker must target the player they mention to see if anyone targeted them. BUT OH WAIT LULZ - the reverse tracker targeted the target to find this out. So now the claim 'Someone targeted Joe Bloggs' has become true, in the very act of confirming the comment. It is a closed loop, impossible to detect lie. Other things: You're saying you know DuD targeted esequiel, and yet: Esequiel was not roleblocked Esequiel was not redirected Esequiel was not protecte Esequiel was not killed Esequiel was not target switched Esequiel does not have a double vote And you are saying you don't believe DuD tracked him? Ok.

Smeagol you just fucked up big. To say that there is more to consider is fine, but to vote DuD is epically ridiculous. Nothing other than 'Moogle could not be reached' has been confirmed. Magnus being a tracker has not been confirmed. I doubt DuD would say such a thing about Diageo unless he was sure Diageo would confirm it (whether it be truth or he's an accomplice). In fact that only reason I could imagine Diageo wouldn't respond is if he himself was Mafia and would stand to benefit by not helping confirm facts.

Why, why why. Why people, why would he confess to being a redirector of his own free will if he was Mafia? It doesn't make sense. Magnus says he was redirected by someone (Dedede was most probably roleblocked so not him) who HAS NOT come forward to say he did this! So either this other redirector is the Mafioso, or Magnus lied. Fuck, this lynch is stupid.

Sorry, crossed wires. But still, to not be told you target makes the result pretty worthless.

Yep. Well, I'll leave it at that. I won't be adding my vote. If lynch happens, it happens. If Dedede has lied, we will surely find out soon enough.

But why would Peeps create a role that just tells you if someone targeted your target? It's not really very useful. And maybe the tracker doesn't want to reveal his role yet.

My point is, your asking Magnus to confirm something tomorrow doesn't mean much. You're pretty suspicious already. Also between 4 Mafiosos, it wouldn't surprise me if one didn't have some level of tracking ability.

What if you're Mafia too?

Oh, yeah. 'Trackers' like Magnus. With any luck we might learn that 'someone targeted Dedede'. Fucking useless. :p

Yes, I'd rather no lynch than lynch someone who I think is town (and potentially of great use to town). If you disagree with such a sentiment then I'd question your alignment. If Dedede has lied anyway he'll be easily enough found out. He will have to target reveal every night and will have trackers wedged up his ass.

I'm not going to lynch him. I don't think he's Mafia based on the roleblocking and claimed redirection by Magnus. I'd rather lynch Magnus himself to find out if the redirection thing was true. Well you would know.

Oh wow. That is catastrophic. If I were Sony I'd be advertising this fact to the max. Just saw this in the comments section

Or we could use logical deduction to cross off potential lynch candidates, thus increasing our chances of striking gold. Dedede is one such I crossed off.

False swipe that badboy into submission.

Why are you being awkward? Obviously the day should end with a lynch. It should NOT end with the lynch of the wrong guy.

More terrible to lynch the wrong guy.

Don't do it.

Aye...no way can they combat cheating when transfer hits. Considering you can download a save off GameFAQs with someone's actual save data then I don't see how it can't be fooled. Shame really.

How would he learn that it he was a tracker? Tracker just learns who they targeted, not usually what they did. In fact you can tell his power had nothing to do with knowing you were protected - he just outright said he couldn't reach you (nothing about who you targeted). So his power didn't even work. Very shifty behaviour from @Esequiel worth noting.

If you're town you won't want the vote being split...if you can say something convincing then you will unsplit it.

It's kinda annoying that you can post a couple of sentences with little justification, just totally ignoring the logic that strongly suggests Dedede could not have been the redirector who sent Magnus somewhere (the redirector who has not come forward). I'll tell you now, if someone here is town and the redirector you are going to get an absolute bollocking for not stepping in.

Maybe share it then? Currently the vote is split on someone you could clear. Split vote = no lynch.

What checks out exactly? The whole point is that his 'info' isn't really info. He could be any other role and still come out with the same story.

What on earth does that prove? That he/teammate targeted you! He has no proof of being the role he says he is. He's says he's a tracker who apparently knows 'someone targeted esequiel' after this was already known.