Sméagol

How can you confirm this? Do you get a PM detailing what happened to you? @Yvonne Are you sure you got a result night 4? I still want the missing targets from people. Diageo, The Peeps especially. Mr-Paul to lesser extent. I believe I have all other targets. And I think I'll put my vote back on. vote mr. Grumpy Forget I asked Yvonne.

I dunno. I can’t recall when Jonnas claimed, but Jimbob was outed fairly early, and he made it till night 5. However, you have another thing going for you, I noticed.. Day 3, you were willing to go for ReZ’s gamble, while Jonnas was on the no lynch list, together with 2 confirmed mafia. When the truth got out (ReZ lied / bluffed), there’s no reason for a mafia member to be on the lynch list.. That would be a huge risk jeopardising your teammember for some credit. It would be safer bet to go for no lynch. At least, that would be my opinion if I were mafia. So there’s that. I’m not confident enough to change my vote, but I’ll remove vote just in case. ###### It isn’t verified, but I jailkept him the night you were roleblocked, so he has nothing to do with it at least.

Yeah sorry. Hmm both trackers? Sméagol - Mr. Tickle - jailkeeper Jonnas - Mr. Rush - protector ReZourceman - Mr. Daydream - tracker Mr-Paul - Mr. Topsy Turvy - name switching Diageo - Mr. Grumpy - protector The Peeps - Mr. Noisy - redirector of sorts - confirmed good (by Jimbob) Yvonne - Mr. Nosy - tracker Anyway, I want target lists. Sméagol 1 - Rush 2 - Topsy Turvy 3 - Topsy Turvy (redirected by Sheikah) 4 - Grumpy 5 - Topsy Turvy 6 - Noisy (redirected by The Peeps) I’d also like to know people’s top 2 suspicions.. There must be 2 left. I was suspecting Diageo and Mr-Paul, however, I have succesfully roleblocked Topsy Turvy three times now, if he was mafia surely I’d have stopped a kill by now. Diageo has been pretty quiet most of the game, and now suddenly he comes out as a protector. That would require an enormous leap of faith for me to vote Jonnas over Diageo.. They are mutually exclusive to me though. Either one or the other. If it’s not Mr-Paul, my only other option is Yvonne.. ReZourceman and The Peeps are town. I’ll have another look at the votes count (if my computer co-operates), but I’m not sure if they really help, especially with the different voting mechanics.. I was wrong about Eevil afterall. ########## Hold on.. I’m trying to do a full target list.. I’m not done yet, but Jonnas’ protection has been verified at least. ################ Thgis should be most of it: Day 1 No lynch Night 1 Sméagol jailkeeps Rush (Jonnas) Rezourceman tracks Strong (result: Strong was roleblocked) Jonnas jailkept Magnus Peterson no action Jimbob investigates Magnus Peterson (result: good) Cube swaps with Jelly (Magnus Peteron) Dedede succesful Rummy succesful Jamba PM name switched Jimbob ?? Yvonne tracks Wrong (Jimbob) (result: Wrong targets Magnus Peterson) // targets players rather than characters Jamba kidnapped (Misschief) Sheikah roleblocked by Lazy (Dedede) ?? Mr-Paul name swaps Jelly (Magnus Peterson?) Diageo ? Mr-Paul ? Day 2 No lynch Night 2 Sméagol jailkeeps Topsy Turvy (Mr-Paul) Cube roleblocks Nosey (Yvonne) Jimbob investigates Noisy (The Peeps) (result: good) Sheikah no action ReZourceman tracks <protected> Lazy (Dedede) (result: lazy whisked away) // lied about it initially Dedede succesful Jonnas protects Lazy (Dedede) Mr-Paul jailkept Magnus Peterson (Clumsy) kidnapped (no action) Eevilmurray roleblocked Nosey (Yvonne) Day 3 Tied Lazy / No lynch result: no lynch No Lynch: Mr Bump, Mr Lazy, Mr Noisy Mr Rush, Mr Strong, Mr Wrong (6) Mr Lazy: Mr Clumsy, Mr Daydream, Mr Grumpy, Mr Jelly, Mr Nosey, Mr Tickle (6) Night 3 Cube roleblocks <protected> Noisy (The Peeps) Sheikah (Strong) kidnapped (redirects Sméagol to Mr-Paul) // mistake by DuD? :p Yvonne tracks Rush (Jonnas) (result: Rush targets The Peeps) Jimbob targets Bump (Rummy) (result: mafia) Mr-Paul no action Rezourceman roleblocked by Lazy (Dedede) ? Eevilmurray no action Day 4 Mr Bump (Rummy) (mafia): Jimbob, Sheikah, Smeagol, ReZourceman, Jonnas, The Peeps, Yvonne, Mr-Paul, EEVILMURRAY, Diageo (10) // player names?? Night 4 Sméagol jailkeeps Grumpy Cube kidnapped roleblocked Funny (Eevilmurray) ReZourceman tracks Lazy (result: Lazy targets Jelly) Yvonne tracks Noisy (result: Noisy targets Diageo) Diageo protects Noisy (The Peeps) Jimbob investigates Noisy (The Peeps) (result: good) Eevilmurray no action Jonnas protects Wrong (Jimbob) Day 5 Mr Lazy (Dedede) (mafia): Mr Daydream, Mr Grumpy, Mr Jelly, Mr Noisy, Mr Nosey, Mr Rush, Mr Tickle, Mr Wrong // no vote: Topsy Turvy, Funny Night 5 Sméagol jailkeeps Topsy Turvy ReZourceman tracks Rush (result: Rush targets Wrong) Jimbob kidnapped Yvonne tracks Funny (Eevilmurray) (result: no / wrong target) Diageo protects Noisy (The Peeps) Jonnas roleblocked // by who? Mr-Paul no action The Peeps redirects Grumpy (Diageo) Day 6 Mr Funny (Eevilmurray) (town) Mr Rush: Mr Daydream, Mr Nosey, Mr Topsy Turvy (3) Mr Funny: Mr Grumpy, Mr Rush, Mr Tickle, Mr Wrong (4) Night 6 Yvonne tracks Rush (Jonnas) (result: Rush targets ReZourceman) Diageo protects Daydream (ReZourceman) Jonnas protects Daydream (ReZourceman) Sméagol jailkeeps Noisy (The Peeps) The Peeps redirects Tickle (Sméagol) There are some inconsistencies.. But I’m wondering if they’re slips or mistakes by DuD.. ###### I take it you tracked Jonnas as well.. ######## @Mr\-Paul I want to see some verification of your power (you state you switch player names with character names in the votecount). Target me, or anyone else, as long you declare your target before the deadline, and stick with it. The only target available of you is Mr Jelly during night 1. Cube has not voted during day 2 unfortunately, so your power is unverified. Still want targets in general.

What I thought. Which must mean the killer ran in protection. Can anyone verify Jonnas or Diageo protecting?

Posting from my phone: @Jonnas, yesterday I did not claim to not have targeted anyone, I claimed to have targeted MR-Paul, but he could not confirm it. @The Peeps, just to be clear, explain your power.. You targeted me right? Also, explain to me why we're voting for the only person who claims the protector role. I want an explanation. Also I still want a complete role list @Diageo @Yvonne. vote: Diageo

Just a heads-up: I’m having major computer problems, so I’m trying to spend as little time on, well the internet, as possible.

No, I believe that was Rummy’s doing.

@Jonnas Don't forget that Eevil has also been confirmed to use laughter to roleblock.. Mr-Paul can’t confirm it, but I really didn’t target you last night. I think we’re on the right track with the lynch of Eevil. That said, there are one or two people left who we know little about. I think it’s time for a full role claim from everyone.. I’ll do a complete list tonight, or just update this incomplete one I’m doing from the top of my head. Sméagol - Mr. Tickle - jailkeeper Eevilmurray - Mr. Funny - roleblocker Jonnas - Mr. Rush - protector ReZourceman - Mr. Daydream - tracker Mr-Paul - Mr. Topsy Turvy - ? Diageo - Mr. Grumpy - ? The Peeps - Mr. Noisy - ? - confirmed good (by Jimbob) Yvonne - Mr. Nosy - ?

Nopes, he’s the (last) roleblocker. I’m the jailkeeper. But yeah, pretty similar. ###### @Jimbob Did you get a last result?

Me or Jonnas? I believe I protect from everything. At least my role PM says no one can get to my target.

I can imagine, just like ReZ obviously is disappointed, but it’s no fun playing in games where activity is faltering anyway, so you’re better off. During the holiday season, activity always falters, I have observed.

Ehm, some screw-ups on both your and my account.. Your screw-up: I’m mr. Tickle. My screw-up: I must admit I’m still cruising on the role list floating in this thread, and still haven’t kept any notes.. I was totally unaware you're are a protector. However. I did not target you.. I targeted mr. Topsy Turvy again. So that would mean Eevil has some explaining to do, unless he’s going to use the excuse I just provided for him.. And while I’m at it, let me just explicitly claim jailkeeper. I’d be looking at Eevil and Diageo. I suggest going after Eevil first.. Actually just vote: Mr. Funny

My game will start exactly when it’s appropriate. Sing-ups will start the 23rd. Perhaps a little break is a good thing?

Although unnecessary, I’ll add my vote (before I go): vote: Mr. Lazy I stopped Mr. Grumpy.

Requiem for a dream [A great list]

Which other day? This is the first mafia he finds.. Isn’t it?

Actually, how do you know you were roleblocked by Mr. Lazy specifically ReZ? You just got a name in your PM?

While it’s true that you being a roleblocker means nothing, you’re original role, well basically also means nothing, which means you’re not confirmed anything. So this deflection is a red flag to me actually. ReZ, how were you roleblocked? Just to complete the picture.. vote: Mr. Bumb

I can confirm Sheikah’s redirection worked.. Mr-Paul either made a mistake, or thought “all characters are known anyway”, and took his target anyway. I once again stopped Topsy Turvy. He was not my original target. ###### To be frank, Dedede’s not got the time to post a little info, yet he does have time to send in his target. I’m happy to continue where we left off yesterday.

@Bob, from memory:

0123456789 Haha. Me and my formatting..

No. Like I said, ReZ pulled a stunt like this before, but I can’t remember the details, or which mafia it actually was. I believe he was town, and I believe the accused was actually mafia afterall, but the lynch didn’t go through because town wasn’t willing to go for it. I’m really not sure, but maybe ReZ himself remembers which mafia I’m talking about, so we can find out. Anyway, that, plus the fact that I expected more out of dedede’s response, is why I’m giving ReZ the benefit of the doubt for now, and it’s why I’m not removing my vote. We can always lynch ReZ afterwards.

###### And @ Peeps: It’s not just based on that anymore. Call ReZ’s stunt anything you want, but dedede’s defense was rather pathetic.

Does anyone else still want to vote / unvote within 10 minutes? Otherwise I’ll post a number.

I’m really inclined to vote for ReZ, problem is, this isn’t the first time he pulled this stunt. Though he was town then, and it almost worked in town’s favour if I recall correctly.. Which doesn’t mean this wouldn’t have been very convenient if this worked now and he was mafia. That said, Dedede’s defense is rather disappointing. I’m also not in favour of a no lynch, it’s either Lazy or Daydream as far as I’m concerned. I’m giving ReZ the benefit of the doubt right now, and I’ll keep my vote where it is.