Tales Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 (He's already told us its both) And in regards to a practical difference, for example a (Pokemafia example) fragile Pokemon gets killed if roleblocked (in some cases...m aybe) ecc blah blah/. I believe that Tales is the sportsman but I also believe the sportsman is mafia. (Oh sorry, Zell not Jayseven. My apologies kind fellow Diageo) I have it on good authority that I am townie. Can't tell you how. /bad joke Exactly why do you think I am mafia?
Cube Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 I don't know why he's looking at me. I jest...thanks, Diageo.
Marcamillian Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 MAIFA TREMBLE BEFORE ME! I AM THE ALMIGHTY PROCASINATOR. FEAR MY ALMIGHTY VOTE LIST! (format is voter - votee - reason... page numbers for reference based on standard 25 posts per page) VOTE LIST DAY 2 pg 2 The Peeps - Smeagol HeroJan - Smeagol chair - Smeagol (diageo refuses Smeagol) Danny: Smeagol Maddog - Smeagol Aqui1a - Smeagol pg 3 Paj - Smeagol Tales - Smeagol Dyson - Smeagol danny - withdraw heroicJan - withdraw - only voting for info pg 4 Chair - Diageo ReZ - Diageo Aqui1a - Diageo Cube - Smeagol Danny - Smeagol ReZ- withdraw Chair - Smeagol HeroicJan - Smeagol Paj - Smeagol Dohnut - Smeagol VOTE LIST DAY 3 pg 6 HeroicJan - Diageo ReZ - Diageo pg 7 Ell - Aqui1a heroicJan - withdraw pg 8 Tales - Diageo VOTE LIST DAY 4 pg9 Ell - Diageo pg10 Maddog - Diageo Cube - Maddog ReZ - Maddog HeroicJan - Maddog Diageo - Maddog pg 12 ReZ - Dohnut Diageo - withdraw Eenuh - Dohnut HeroicJan - Dohnut Diageo - Dohnut pg13 cube - Dohnut Maddog - Dohnut Peeps - Dohnut Diageo - Withdraw pg14 Diageo - dlt pg 15 Peeps - ReZ pg 16 ReZ - withdraw maddog - withdraw HeroicJan - chairdriver Tales - dohnut Diageo - ReZ pg 17 Maddog - Rez danny - ReZ Cube - ReZ ReZ - Chair Dohnut - ReZ pg18 heroic - withdraw heroicJan - ReZ Peeps - withdraw Peeps - ReZ gmac - ReZ VOTE LIST DAY 5 Pg 20 MadDog - Cube - "duke" Pg 21 Jay - MadDog - cant remember, jump on cube, tentative Pg 22 Cube - Ell - Bribary The Peeps - gmac - inactivity Cube - gmac Ell - Diageo - cant target pg 23 Diageo - Gmac - inactivity heroicjanitor - gmac pg 24 nintendohnut - diageo danny - Diageo - suspicious danny - withdraw pg 26 Rummy - Diageo Maddog - Diageo pg 29 Maddog - ReZ - Name stall jay - ReZ - lolz Tales - Diageo Peeps - withdraw pg 31 Zell - Diageo - fishy mr-paul - Jay - roleblock description pg 32 heroicJan - jay the peeps - jay - dont knwo much Diageo - jay - give information pg 33 Zell - jay - pressure Peeps - RUmmy - bad logic pg 34 Jay - Diageo - padding thread Diageo - removed HeroicJan - removed mr-paul - remove vote Diageo - Rummy - R suspects him, hero, peeps, Rez pg 35 heroicJan- Gmac Ell - gmac - following crowd Diageo - gmac - "willing to" ?? ReZ - gmac - not in propper format "I am also willing to " pg 36 Eenuh - gmac - no contribution Rummy - gmac - pains him to VOTE LIST DAY 6 pg 37 ReZ - Marcamillian ThePeeps - Marcamillian ThePeeps - remove vote - just got role pg 38 ReZ - Remove Vote - Not had time to post ThePeeps - Rummy - not adressing fencing Diageo - Gmac - resume last day pg 39 Diageo - Rummy - disproves people pg 40 Maddog - Gmac - dont like the sound of Cube - Gmac - willing to Tales - gmac - sounds good ThePeeps - Gmac Diageo - gmac - he's homo Marcamillian - gmac - not princess pg 41 Cube - remove vote - discussion pg 43 ReZ - gmac Cube - Gmac - found out everything we can today (majority reached) ThePeeps - RemoveVote - CubeReZ relationship pg 44 ThePeeps - Gmac - day ending mr-paul - gmac - majority (the peeps had said one till majority - forgot about double vote) VOTE LIST DAY 7 pg 45 Maddog - Zell - map stealing HeriocJ - Zell - map & existing suspicions Cube - Zell pg 46 ThePeeps - Zell - info/inactive/convenient map Jay - Zell HeriocJ - RemoveVote ThePeeps - RemoveVote Maddog - Tales Cube - Tales ReZ - Tales Diageo - RemoveVote
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 Nice to see Diageo and Cube so active however there is one thing... No reply? I wonder why you havn't pushed for a response Diageo? Surely this would go a long was to absolving the suspicion on you. Of course if I wanted to be bloody minded I would say that even if he does confirm he could be a mafia conspiritor... one way to go about it would be to kill you and then we know for sure that Cube and HeroicJanitor are good! The fact that he just didn't respond instead of actively calling me a liar was enough. Also I wasn't being voted at.
The Peeps Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 Nothing suspicious jumps out at me from that list so far... not sure how much use it'll be but it's a good reference to have, so thanks Marc. At a loss for where to go from here. I think it's quite likely that someone who has been active throughout is mafia but I couldn't say who. I think this is the list of people who have yet to roleclaim anyway: Rezourceman HeroicJanitor Nintendohnut We know about everyone else don't we?
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 Does someone want to give me a quick list of the remaining players?
Tales Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 -Cube -Dannyboy-the-Dane -Diageo -Eenuh -heroicjanitor -Jayseven -MadDog -Marcamillian -Nintendohnut -ReZourceman -Rummy -Tales -The Peeps -Zell
The Peeps Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 We've got 5 dead townies (Diageo[original], The Peeps[original], Ellmeister, Mr-Paul and Dyson) And 3 dead fuckin, gmafia scumnags (Sméagol, Chairdriver and Gmac)
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 -Cube -Dannyboy-the-Dane -Diageo -Eenuh -heroicjanitor -Jayseven -MadDog -Marcamillian -Nintendohnut -ReZourceman -Rummy -Tales -The Peeps -Zell The ones in bold are the ones I believe over 80% that they are good. I'm willing to go for any of the others. The most prominent being Tales. Vote: Tales
The Peeps Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 I'm not sure if anyone actually has anything on Tales except mild suspicion due to him not being as active as others. Yeah it did work with Gmac but is it likely to happen again? I won't vote for Tales until there's some actual evidence of wrong doing. I'll probably vote at the end if you're waiting for majority though. *going to look back through the thread now*
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 This has something to do with it. Remove voteOh god, i'm an idiot. I read my PM at least 3 times, to make sure i had my wording correct, and each time i totally misread the beginning. The PM says the map stolen from Zell, not stolen by Zell, as i first read it. So he is telling the truth about being robbed. Zell, i am very very sorry. Since Zell looks to be a townie, we could probably narrow down the list of who has voted for him today, and possibly catch a mafioso. For now though, Change Vote: Tales.
Tales Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 I haven't voted for Zell and a sportman doesn't sound like a robber does it?
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 You voted for me because you don't like me. Doesn't seem like a good reason.
Jonnas Posted November 18, 2010 Author Posted November 18, 2010 Does someone want to give me a quick list of the remaining players? Fun fact: The first post has links for every write-up. Just click on the most recent day.
Cube Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 -Marcamillian -Nintendohnut I believe that they can be added to the good list.
Tales Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 You voted for me because you don't like me. Doesn't seem like a good reason. A lot of people did.
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 I believe there's a 65% chance does are townie. You can however add them to your good list. A lot of people did. They gave a better reason than "I don't like you," even if it was the underlying cause. Also I don't believe you roleblocked me because you were suspicious.
The Peeps Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 Tales, why did you target Rez for roleblocking on Night 4 when he was already unable to do anything due to being in a catatonic state? ReZ has been silenced for the day. He will not be able to utilise his power during the following night, either. Should he break his silence, death will swiftly come.
Tales Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 Because I didn't pay much attention to the thread for a little while. That's why I didn't do anything on night 3. When night 4 came aroud I just picked a random target. I didn't know he was catatonic.
The Peeps Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 Doesn't really seem like a mistake you'd make if you were mafia. At least one of them would be paying attention to the thread and would've said about Rez. I'm just not really suspicious of Tales...
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 (edited) Or he's lying about targeting Rez. I'm going to Remove Vote while I ponder over this a little longer. -Cube -Dannyboy-the-Dane -Diageo -Eenuh -heroicjanitor -Jayseven -MadDog -Marcamillian -Nintendohnut -ReZourceman -Rummy -Tales -The Peeps -Zell There has to about 2 mafia left. Everyone can't be townie. If we take away Zell, Marcamillian, Nintendohnut and Tales. We are left with Jayseven, Rummy, Dannyboy and Eenuh. Or else there's someone who appears good when investigated. Hang on a minute. If Tales wasn't really reading over the thread he could have not been reading over the mafia thread either. He could have not even told his mafia brother that he targeted Rez. Vote Tales again. Edited November 18, 2010 by Diageo Automerged Doublepost
Tales Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 The mafia doesn't need a player's approval when they make him do something. When I was mafia in Pokemafia 7, we told Rez(GM) what he and he would do that night without asking for approval or anything. If that what you were talking about.
Diageo Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 That's not what I'm talking about. Also you could have just made up that you targeted Rez and no one on those two nights because you did the killing on those two nights.
ReZourceman Posted November 18, 2010 Posted November 18, 2010 No he isn't lying about targeting me that night. The PM I received indicates that he challenged me to a match of tennis, but being catatonic I couldn't play ball (ala Marcamillians fencing matches I guess) and that an inconsiderate swing sent me flying to the bushes. It doesn't exactly sound like a roleblocking, and Marcamillian is almost 100% a townie (due to his claims he's made and he has posted several times with hugely helpful posts for town, not least the vote correlation post a few above this one) so supposedly town have two roleblockers with near identical roles but ones a fencing and the other is general sports? I don't but it at all chaps, so my vote most certainly stays henceforth on Tales, yest further evidence be bought to light.
Recommended Posts