Posted April 21, 2007 Come on guys we all have different opinions no need to kick each other in balls. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 But this is the internet what else is it for :P Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 I can't stand Girlfriend. It's irritating...and you can tell she's trying too hard. By throwing "motherfucking" in there. Shock horror! Other than that...there's nothing particularly inspiring about her music. Pretty generic chord structures, slightly whiny voice (it is, it has that annoying twinge to it). Although not as bad as FOB mind She's just nothing special, bit generic. Although it's not utterly offensive. Her singing's not atrocious but it's not exactly agreeable. Chloe Alper FTW. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Her song, "I'm with you" is an absolute classic. At least everyone of her songs sounds completly different from the others she makes. Her voice sounds great live too.(most the time) http://youtube.com/watch?v=R9Z26Pn0lmk Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 and you can tell she's trying too hard.That's it! Thank you for phrasing the exact reason why I don't like her (and Ashlee Simpson and the likes). They're trying hard to be badass punk rock chicks but they're not; they try to find a mid way between Britney pop and Green Day punk and it's just not a good mix in my opinion. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Unlinke all the other pop brats, she has actually found that mix. She started out being a rock/punk kinda tomboy, and has since grown up, and so has her music. Unlike the other wannabes who try to be like she was, they have tried to copy her and in my mind have failed miserabley. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Unlinke all the other pop brats, she has actually found that mix. She started out being a rock/punk kinda tomboy, and has since grown up, and so has her music. Unlike the other wannabes who try to be like she was, they have tried to copy her and in my mind have failed miserabley. Heh you're really growing out to be a fanboy now :wink: Anyway, it has been noted by several reviewers (haven't heard anything besides Girlfriend) that her music has seen no actual progress over the last three albums... Even if the growth is there, I find it hard to believe that going more mainstream pop is a good way of growing up, but that's a question of musical taste. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 That's it! Thank you for phrasing the exact reason why I don't like her (and Ashlee Simpson and the likes). They're trying hard to be badass punk rock chicks but they're not; they try to find a mid way between Britney pop and Green Day punk and it's just not a good mix in my opinion. +1 Avril Lavigne for me is a bit meh because someone like Karen O can pull off the whole rock chick thing with 100x more style and charisma. Maps completely pwns I'm With You by the way Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 By throwing "motherfucking" in there. Shock horror! . Wait, so swearing means trying too hard nowadays? I personally like Girlfriend, it took a few listens but it's ok. Listening to the album now, just started track 3. 2 was a bit average. I'l update as I go. wait wtf! Aaand iiiiiii feel soo aliiiive. P.O.D anyone? Apparently she wears pants (trousers) XD - She does the metalcore 'scream' in track 9. This gets funnier and funnier. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Wait, so swearing means trying too hard nowadays? No, the way it's thrown in is incredibly forced and it doesn't flow. Unnecessary use of swearing is trying too hard when it comes to music. And it's definitely unnecessary in that song. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 No, the way it's thrown in is incredibly forced and it doesn't flow. Unnecessary use of swearing is trying too hard when it comes to music. And it's definitely unnecessary in that song. It does fit though, it wouldn't fit the beat without it :/ Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 She can't sing, and is ugly. Lord knows what people see in her. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Actually if you listen to the whole line it seems like it's been structured around the "motherfucking" so in the general scheme it doesn't fit. But my main point is that it's unnecessary and a blatant attempt to appear more "badass". Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 I haven't heard the album, but I do rather like Girlfriend and the video, and I think she looks rather good these days. Reminds me of a girl I used to know. Actually if you listen to the whole line it seems like it's been structured around the "motherfucking" so in the general scheme it doesn't fit. But my main point is that it's unnecessary and a blatant attempt to appear more "badass". My mate used to have a habit of having one random swearword in every song that he wrote, he never really explained why though. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 My review 1. Girlfriend - great song, catchy beat. 2. I can do Better - Average - little bland 3. Runaway - Awesome song, great lyrics, catchy tune 4. The best damn thing - Different sound for her, very upbeat, great chorus 5. When you're gone - One of the best songs shes done, Great emotion 6. Everything back but you - 7. Hot - Sounds awesome, fun, just want to dance to song, The best on the album 8. Innocence - Not as good as her usually ballady song, its alright, not great 9. I dont have to try - Worst song on the album, great beat, lyrics not right 10. One of those girls - Easy to listen too, but forgettable 11. Contagious - Superb song, (rolling stone magazine said it was one of the best this year) awesome beat, great lyrics, fun!! 12.keep holding on - Back to what she does best, ballads, great song, I can really relate to the lyrics. 9/10 for the album One or two forgettable songs but all in all shes back and at her best. Critics reviews Rolling stone - 4 out of 5 The gaurdian - 4 out of 5 All music guide - 4.5 out of 5 Entertainment weekly - B So far its got better/on par reviews with her first album and much better than her last one. Heh you're really growing out to be a fanboy now :wink: Anyway, it has been noted by several reviewers (haven't heard anything besides Girlfriend) that her music has seen no actual progress over the last three albums... Even if the growth is there, I find it hard to believe that going more mainstream pop is a good way of growing up, but that's a question of musical taste. lol i have to admit i sound like one, but i', not, shes not even my favourite singer/band, that acolade goes to "the academy is.." But i just get peed off when people say shes like britney or ashley etc, shes not, she can actually sing and write her own songs. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 OK, finished listening to the album. I thought it was a bit bland with a couple of notable songs. Notably Girlfriend, The Best Damn Thing, Everything Back But You, Hot, The scream on I don't Have To Try (it's hilarious). Everything else I thought was a bit 'meh'. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 I never liked her bullshit. Especially shite like Sk8er Boi was just stereotypical bullshit. And if she hadn't done it, i wouldn't get retarrds and chavs sing it at me. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 I'd love to rag her. Hahahha. Nicely put. But, get to the back of the queue. Dante, some more Avril eye candy would be greately appreciated. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Hahahha. Nicely put. But, get to the back of the queue. Dante, some more Avril eye candy would be greately appreciated. Hahaha. Yeh, may as well turn this into another Avril eye candy thread. Dante, get on it. :wink: Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Can't stand her music (never liked it) and she has an annoying voice. And sometimes I want to punch her in the face for some reason. There's something about her that makes me hate her. Also, Girlfriend is one of the worst songs ever. The music is horrible, her singing kinda sucks and the text is the worst. Sounds like a 13 year old or something. Sorry. I just don't like her. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Posted April 21, 2007 Hahahha. Nicely put. But, get to the back of the queue. Dante, some more Avril eye candy would be greately appreciated. Okay Fierce Link. Avril Lavigne Avril Lavigne pictures Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
