Jump to content
N-Europe

Is it any good?  

8 members have voted

  1. 1. Is it any good?

    • Yes
      1
    • No
      4
    • Not Fussed
      3


Recommended Posts

Posted

Is this good, and should i carry on?

 

  Reveal hidden contents
Posted

I'm not even going to read it until you put it in the creative board, where it should be and where everyone should do more stuff besides rating avatars and signatures.

Posted
  jayseven said:
I'm not even going to read it until you put it in the creative board, where it should be and where everyone should do more stuff besides rating avatars and signatures.

I didnt post it in there because its dead, as always.

If someone moves it, thanks. But if its not moved it not really causing a problem here.

Posted
  warandchaos said:
I didnt post it in there because its dead, as always.

If someone moves it, thanks. But if its not moved it not really causing a problem here.

 

Well clearly the reaction it's received here shows just how right you are.

 

Creative board would be nowhere near as dead if threads like this were put in there in the first place, or if people like you gave back to the board and commented on what others have to offer.

Posted
  jayseven said:
Well clearly the reaction it's received here shows just how right you are.

 

Creative board would be nowhere near as dead if threads like this were put in there in the first place, or if people like you gave back to the board and commented on what others have to offer.

If it bothers you so much, report it. Its simple...

I wanted it to be seen, so i posted it here...

Posted

To be honest...

 

-I dislike the first person view immensly. That might just be my preference though.

 

-It goes on too long too similarly about "battling the weather".

 

-Some of your images are totally ineffective. Rain bursting just feels wrong, carefully collapse makes no sense. In the opening paragraph, "eventually flowing off my chin" gives a sense of stillness, as he is very aware of this, not at all like the tempest he's meant to be in.

 

- Various grammatical errors etc.

 

-Some bits I liked however, I like the bit about the wind wanting you to stay. The bit about droppings you can taste is effecitve, though cut out "waste" and "droppings" for something stronger.

Posted

I liked it, there was just too much use of 'I'. I know it's in first person but still, try and vary it a bit.

 

 

-regardless of what people say I'd recommend you to carry on. I once wrote the beggining of a story (a couple of years ago), read through it, thought it was crap and binned it. Now I really wish I still had it to look over and, since I'm now older and wiser, reckon I could've made it a lot better. So yeah never bin it

Posted
  Ninty 182 said:
I liked it, there was just too much use of 'I'. I know it's in first person but still, try and vary it a bit.

 

 

-regardless of what people say I'd recommend you to carry on. I once wrote the beggining of a story (a couple of years ago), read through it, thought it was crap and binned it. Now I really wish I still had it to look over and, since I'm now older and wiser, reckon I could've made it a lot better. So yeah never bin it

I ming t continue it when im bored again.

 

  jayseven said:
So is my opinion worth anything yet, warandchaos?
I didnt say it wasnt worth anything, i said it wasnt doing any harm where it was.
×
×
  • Create New...