Hehe, that was a fun game. Sorry for the Eden SNAFU, I was honestly confused by the mafia forum thing:
Yvonne:
what does this mean:
At no point do you reveal you hold this Piece of Eden
do I get punished if I say I have a piece of eden?
Jimbob:
Basically, there are 3 pieces of Eden. You reveal you hold a piece, it will only make it easier for those who have a piece to acquire it as they'll know who has one.
After which I assumed it was actually just advice, and that if I thought it was a tactical advantage, I could just reveal.
Everyone knows how I don't like to play against the spirit of a game design, so it especially sucks that I broke this aspect of it, and for that I apologise!
Anyway it was fun faffing around and lying outrageously, and I think the game was designed nicely to give town enough to go on and mafia enough room to make stuff up. Your games keep getting better!