The Peeps

changevote zell don't know why I put marcamillian earlier. Cube is right, maddog said he was fenced which proves he didn't use a kill power.

Vote: Marcamillian based on what HeroicJanitor said about him and Tales. Jayseven Cube Zell Marcamillian One of these people is the killer and I believe Jayseven and Cube are townie.

Good point

Either you or cube is lying. I believe Zell was redirected to Jayseven and Marcamillian was redirected to MadDog. Jayseven was not redirected... Which leaves Cube as the third misdirected guest. Right now I'm thinking Cube looks pretty suspicious.

Diageo stop saying what I'm saying :P

So now you have a protection power too? ugh

Who did you talk to who could give you that information? And yeah, what Diageo said.

Zell Jayseven Marcamillian ^all targeted jayseven or maddog - assuming Jay wasn't bluffing about targeting himself and not including myself obviously. Zell could have targeted MadDog directly - possibly the one guest who knew where his target was. Jayseven - I don't know what would happen with him. It doesn't make sense that he wouldn't be able to target himself really. - also possibly the one guest who knew where his target was. Marcamillian must have targeted Jayseven - he's one of the three misdirected guests.

It could be but I would've expected a townie to come forward if they took a map from Zell because it would've helped prove Zell's innocence. It seems more likely to me that the mafia took the map from Zell.

If Zell is mafia, a townie must have stolen the map and should come forward. If Zell is town, the mafia likely stole the map. I know it doesn't clear him but it takes a lot of my suspicion of him away. Diageo, why Jayseven? -- Zell are you 100% sure you reached MadDog?

Unless Cube wants to do one... Things you shouldn't say in Church

These posts are all true then. Remove vote

Doesn't make sense unless Jayseven was bluffing and actually targeted someone else. If he chose to protect himself then I'm not entirely sure what effect I would have on him. Either I switch him to protect MadDog, or I could only redirect from MadDog to Jayseven and not the other way around (which I was hoping would be the case).

Correct me if I'm wrong but we were assuming Cube to be mafia and he isn't. Which means there's one more to find because Paj and Ellmeister's posts only add up to 3 and there were 5 mafia posts on that page. The only person left alive with 2 posts on the page Marcamillian investigated is you. If Cube is neutral then Jonnas is mafia. Well if Marcamillian says that then I'll accept it. I'm sure he specifically said mafia posts though.

haha yeah it has Would be brilliant if it hadn't though.

So the protector (Marcamillian?) is the one that knew where the room was? This means I may well have switched Jay from targeting himself which would be odd. If Jay targeted himself at all that is - I'm only going by what he said in the thread in the previous day phase. I know for certain anyway that 3 people were misdirected but 1 person could not be.

That is what I currently believe. I'm such an idiot though.

Well to get MadDog he would've had to have targeted Jayseven who was already under his own protection. Maybe Marcamillian just wanted to be extra sure Jay was protected. I was suspicious of him after all that but, remembering that he's a jailkeeper and not a roleblocker, I'm back to trusting him again.

lol even though I said it myself earlier I forgot about Marcamillian being a jailkeeper. Yep that would make sense.

and I've already said one person who targeted my targets wasn't redirected.

Jayseven targeted himself though

--- So if the killer tried to target MadDog they would've found Jayseven and if they had tried to target Jayseven, they would have got Jayseven. That is potentially how things played out but it might just be coincidence or whatever. -- lol I'm wrong then. So if the killer tried to kill Jay and ended up with MadDog... why didn't MadDog die?

If I've got this right, my power worked like this last night: Jayseven was protected so I couldn't target him. Anyone targeting Jayseven would reach Jayseven. I could target MadDog, therefore anyone targeting MadDog would reach Jayseven. I think the person that already knew where his target's room was would've been Jayseven meaning he was able to protect himself and not get misdirected to MadDog.

Really? lol well done then. IF that's true... Jonnas is mafia.

It was more to do with that than Cube actually voting for himself